Sammy's Shrimp Box
Make a booking
- Good for special occasions
- Romantic
- Good for groups
Additional information
- Dining styleCasual Dining
- Price$30 and under
- CuisinesSeafood, Italian, Spanish
- Phone number(718) 885-3200
- Dress codeCasual Dress
- AreaCity Island
- Parking detailsNone
Popular dishes
Menu
Sammy's Famous Complimentary offerings - Every table receives two home baked breads, one being our famous white Crusty Mountain Bread and the other our one of a kind Cornbread served with a wedge of delicious cheese. Followed by our iced relish tray. Every dinner come with our special Garden Salad with a choice of dressing as well as Spanish Rice and freshly Sauteed Veggies and finally every entree comes with your choice of French Fries, fried sweet potato, tostones, baked potato or linguine in white or red sauce
Sea Treasures
Littleneck or Cherrystone Clams
- Served (6)USD 9.95
- Served (12)USD 15.95
Blue Point Oysters
served individually
- eachUSD 2.75
Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail (5)USD 14.95
Calamari SaladUSD 14.95
Chiller PlatterUSD 19.95
iced combo of shrimp, clams & oysters
Baked Clams
- (6)USD 9.95
- (12)USD 16.95
Clams Casino (8)USD 15.95
Clams in Garlic Sauce or Red Sauce (Hot or Sweet)USD 17.95
Soft Shell Steamers (Ipswich)
- MKT Price
Oysters Rockefeller (6)USD 17.95
creamed spinach & mozzarella
Fresh Tender MusselsUSD 15.95
cooked in Garlic or Red Sauce
Fried CalamariUSD 13.95
Hot AntipastoUSD 29.95
served for 2
Piri Piri Shrimp AppetizerUSD 16.95
Spicy Hot
Coconut ShrimpUSD 16.95
Bang-Bang ShrimpUSD 15.95
Mozzarella SticksUSD 10.95
Calamari in Red Sauce (Sweet or Hot)USD 15.95
Maryland Lump Crab Cakes (1)USD 14.95
Fried Clam StripsUSD 12.95
Order of TostonesUSD 5.95
Spicy Buffalo WingsUSD 12.95
Buffalo Wings & Buffalo ShrimpUSD 15.95
Sammy's Chowders
Manhattan Clam ChowderUSD 6.95
New England Clam ChowderUSD 6.95
French Onion SoupUSD 6.95
Lobster BisqueUSD 7.95
Sammy's Fried Specialties
Our Famous Jumbo Fried ShrimpUSD 26.95
Fried Coconut ShrimpUSD 27.95
Fried Calamari PlatterUSD 21.95
Fried Day Boat Sea ScallopsUSD 32.95
Choice of Fried Porgies or Fried Cod FishUSD 23.95
Fried WhitingUSD 23.95
Fried Lobster TailsUSD 34.95
Fried Clam Strip PlatterUSD 21.95
Fried Blue FishUSD 21.95
Fried OystersUSD 24.95
Crispy Soft Shell Crabs (Jumbo (2) Two)USD 26.95
Fried Fillet of SoleUSD 27.95
Southern Style Fried ChickenUSD 21.95
Fried Whole Red SnapperUSD 36.95
Fried Shrimp & ScallopsUSD 33.95
Authentic Fish & ChipsUSD 24.95
Cod Fish, the best for Fish & Chips
Chicken Finger PlatterUSD 19.95
Super Fried Seafood Combo PlatterUSD 39.95
One of our many specialties; Shrimp, Fillet of Fish, Scallops & Calamari deep fried to crispy perfection. A Sammy's favorite!
Jumbo Shrimp Combination
Each Shrimp Combination starts with our famous colossal size Shrimp which can be prepared Fried or Scampi style. Then add your own favorite fresh fish selection. Served Broiled or Fried
Shrimp & Fillet of SoleUSD 39.95
Shrimp & PorgyUSD 32.95
Shrimp & WhitingUSD 32.95
Shrimp & TilapiaUSD 32.95
Shrimp & Whole Red SnapperUSD 42.95
Shrimp & Alaskan SalmonUSD 39.95
Shrimp & Stripped BassUSD 36.95
Shrimp & Fried ChickenUSD 27.95
Sammy's Chef Specials
All of our chef specials are prepared to order. They are first baked in our famous Scampi Sauce, then popped under the broiler. Any fish entree can also be grilled, sauteed or prepared cajun style. Any item can be stuffed with crabmeat for $16.95
Jumbo Shrimp ScampiUSD 27.95
Jumbo Stuffed ShrimpUSD 42.95
w/Crabmeat
Caribbean Shrimp ScampiUSD 29.95
Coconut & Curry
Shrimp FlorentineUSD 29.95
Deep Sea Scallops a la ScampiUSD 29.95
Broiled Shrimp & ScallopsUSD 32.95
Baked Fillet of SoleUSD 29.95
Baked Fillet of Sole FlorentineUSD 34.95
stuffed w/ Spinach & Muenster Cheese
Fillet of SaleUSD 39.95
stuffed w/ Crabmeat or Jumbo Shrimp
Baked Ocean Blue FishUSD 24.95
Alaskan Salmon FiletUSD 29.95
Baked Atlantic Cod SteakUSD 26.95
Baked Whole Red Snapper (Head On)USD 37.95
North Atlantic SwordfishUSD 32.95
Whole Striped Bass (Head On)USD 29.95
Fresh Tuna SteakUSD 29.95
Wild TilapiaUSD 27.95
Chilean Sea Bass (Fresh)USD 34.95
Fresh Halibut SteakUSD 32.95
w/ lemon butter or Mustard sauce
CatfishUSD 26.95
Seafood SkewerUSD 39.95
1/2 - Lobster tail, sea scallops, shrimp, king crabs, sword fish, fillet of sole over cajun rice
Single 7oz. Lobster TailUSD 24.95
Twin Lobster TailsUSD 43.95
Twin Lobster Tail Platter
stuffed w/ Crabmeat or Shrimp; add $7 per tail
Jumbo Snow Crab LegsUSD 37.95
Crab Leg CombinationUSD 59.95
Alaskan King Crab Legs & Snow Crab legs
Alaskan King Crab Legs
Jumbo Order
- MKT
Sammy's Broiled CombinationUSD 39.95
Our House Specialty here at Sammy's Fish Box! This combination comes with Shrimp, Scallops, Fillet of Fish, Baked Clams, Baked Mussels, & 1/2 a Lobster Tail
Maryland Lump Crab Cake DinnerUSD 29.95
Two (2) Large Crab Cakes
Traditional New England Split Open Lobster RollUSD 29.95
served with coleslaw, french fries or potato chips & pickle
Pacific Northwest Wood Roasted Fish
Native Americans pioneered the net of Roasting Fish on wood planks. European settlers then added seasonings enhancing the aroma and flavors imparted by the planks. This tradition has been renewed at Sammy's where your fish is baked on authentic alder wood planks
Red SnapperUSD 38.95
SwordfishUSD 34.95
Chilean Sea BassUSD 36.95
HalibutUSD 33.95
SalmonUSD 32.95
TunaUSD 33.95
Whole Striped BassUSD 29.95
Italian Specialties
Jumbo Shrimp in Garlic or Red SauceUSD 29.95
served in a pot over fresh pasta
LinguineUSD 23.95
with Red or White Clam Sauce
CalamariUSD 24.95
in a red sauce, hot, sweet or garlic
Chicken FranceseUSD 24.95
Shrimp FranceseUSD 29.95
Shrimp RisottoUSD 29.95
Seafood RisottoUSD 39.95
Veggie RisottoUSD 21.95
Sammy's Shrimp ParmigianaUSD 28.95
Chicken & Shrimp Parmigiana ComboUSD 27.95
Eggplant ParmigianaUSD 19.95
Chicken ParmigianaUSD 22.95
Pot of Succulent Rope MusselsUSD 19.95
Cooked in a Garlic White Wine or Marinara Sauce. Can he served over pasta or with French fries
Pasta Del MarUSD 34.95
in Red or Garlic Sauce; A Whole Lobster served with Clams & Mussels over a bed of fresh pasta (Hot or Sweet)
Our Fabulous Feasts for 2 or More
Your Choice $119.95
Italian Feast
Lobster, Shrimp, Clams, Mussels, Snow Crab Legs, Scallops and King Crab Legs all served on a bed of fresh pasta in Red or Garlic Sauce
Paella de Espana
This authentic Spanish Dish is loaded with Jumbo Shrimp, Sea Scallops, Clams, Mussels, Maine Lobster, Snow Legs, King Crab Legs, tender Chicken and Chorizo (Pork Sausage) sauteed with Spanish yellow rice
The Crab & Lobster Feast
A Whole 1-1/4 lb. Maine Lobster with King Crab Legs, Snow Crab Legs, Crab Catch of the Day & Jumbo Fried Shrimp; all served over a bed of yellow rice
Super BBQ Feast
King Crab Legs, Snow Crab Legs, Fried Shrimp, Full Rack of Ribs, 1/2 a BBQ Chicken; all served over a bed of yellow rice
Cold Seafood Feast
2 Whole 1-1/4lb. Maine Lobsters, Shrimp Cocktail, Snow Crab Legs, Clams & Mussels; all served over rice
Sammy's Famous Montauk Chiller Seafood Tower
Seafood ChillerUSD 69.95
Whole lobster, Shrimp Cocktail, Clams, fresh Oysters, Mussels and Calamari salad
Live Maine Lobsters
Only Live Maine Lobsters are good enough for Sammy's; All Lobsters can be stuffed with shrimp or crabmeat at an additional charge
Clam Bake SpecialUSD 39.95
A succulent platter consisting of whole 1-1/2 lb. Maine lobster ipswich (Based on availability or substitute w/littleneck steamers) steamers, baked potato, corn on the cob and piping hot drawn butter. "Quite a bake"!
Whole Broiled or Steamed 1-1/4 Lb. LobsterUSD 23.95
- Stuffed with Crabmeat or ShrimpUSD 16.95
Whole Broiled or Steamed 1-1/2 Lbs. Maine LobsterUSD 29.95
- Stuffed with Crabmeat or ShrimpUSD 16.95
Whole Broiled or Steamed 2 Lbs-Maine LobsterUSD 42.95
- Stuffed with Crabmeat or ShrimpUSD 16.95
Jumbo 3 Lbs. 4 Lb. to 5 Lb. Maine Lobster
stuffed with crabmeat or shrimp $16.95
- Market Price
Whole Maine Lobster & Tender Fried ShrimpUSD 43.95
- Stuffed with Crabmeat or ShrimpUSD 16.95
Whole Maine Lobster & Shrimp ScampiUSD 43.95
- Stuffed with Crabmeat or ShrimpUSD 16.95
Whole Maine Lobster & Baby Back RibsUSD 39.95
- Stuffed with Crabmeat or ShrimpUSD 16.95
Whole Maine Lobster & New York Shell SteakUSD 49.95
- Stuffed with Crabmeat or ShrimpUSD 16.95
2 Lb. Lobster NewburgUSD 43.95
Shell Fish ExtravaganzaUSD 69.95
A Whole Maine Lobster, Scallops, Snow Crab Legs, Shrimp, Baked Clams, and Fillet of Fish; Feast for one
Sammy's Trio's
Snow Crab Legs, Lobster Tail & ShrimpUSD 54.95
King Crab Legs, Lobster Tail & Fried ShrimpUSD 69.95
Lobster Tail, Steak & Fried ShrimpUSD 59.95
Lobster Special
Twin (2 Whole) 1-1/4 Lb. LobstersUSD 39.95
Can be stuffed with Crabmeat or Shrimp for an additional charge
Surf & Turf At Sammy's
Snow Crab Legs & Fried ShrimpUSD 42.95
Snow Crab Legs & Shrimp ScampiUSD 42.95
Snow Crab Legs & Lobster TailUSD 43.95
Snow Crab Legs & RibsUSD 39.95
Snow Crab Legs & Shell SteakUSD 44.95
Baby Back Ribs (Pork) & Fried ShrimpUSD 39.95
Lobster Tail & Fried ShrimpUSD 39.95
Lobster Tail & Baby Back RibsUSD 39.95
Lobster Tail & Filet MignonUSD 54.95
Lobster Tail & N.Y. Shell SteakUSD 49.95
New York Steak & Fried ShrimpUSD 43.95
Jumbo Fried Shrimp & Filet MignonUSD 45.95
King Crab Legs & Fried ShrimpUSD 54.95
King Crab Legs & Baby Back RibsUSD 49.95
King Crab Legs & Shell SteakUSD 54.95
King Crab Legs & Lobster TailUSD 59.95
King Crab Legs & Fillet MignonUSD 59.95
Chicken Surf & TurfUSD 49.95
Served with BBQ ribs or chicken w/ steak, your choice. Snow crab legs or fried shrimp
Chicago Rib Eye & Shrimp or 7oz. TailUSD 49.95
your choice
For Prime Steak Lovers
Chicago Style Bone-In Rib Eye Steak (20 Oz.)USD 39.95
16 Oz. Prime Shell SteakUSD 36.95
Filet MignonUSD 39.95
Sammy's Famous Sirloin BurgerUSD 15.95
King Cut Prime RibUSD 34.95
served on the bone or without, your choice
Our Famous Baby Back Ribs (Pork)USD 28.95
Baby Back Pork Ribs with BBQ ChickenUSD 27.95
Real Juicy BBQ ChickenUSD 21.95
Piri Piri Shrimp or Red Snapper
Piri Piri Shrimp or Red Snapper
Spicy Hot! An extremely popular dish throughout Africa, Portugal & Brazil pan seared Shrimp or Red Snapper. w/ olive oil, garlic, cilantro, chillies, parsley and lemon juice
- ShrimpUSD 29.95
- Red SnapperUSD 38.95
Cajun Fish Magic
Blackened Swordfish or HalibutUSD 31.95
Blackened Chilean Sea BassUSD 35.95
Blackened SalmonUSD 29.95
Blackened TilapiaUSD 28.95
Sammy's Luncheon Menu
All Lunch Entrees are served with Tomato Juice or Melon Slice, Manhattan Clam Chowder or New England Clam Chowder or Salad plus your choice of Baked Potato, Tostones, Fries or Linguine. Coffee or Tea and Ice Cream. Lunch served from 11:30 a.m. to 3:00 p.m. Monday through Saturday. All lunch item can be stuffed with crabmeat for an additional charge
Main
Jumbo Fried ShrimpUSD 21.95
Fisherman's Fried ComboUSD 29.95
Authentic Fish & ChipsUSD 17.95
Fried PorgyUSD 18.95
Fried Fillet of SoleUSD 19.95
Fried Catfish PlatterUSD 17.95
Fried ScallopsUSD 23.95
Jumbo Shrimp ScampiUSD 19.95
Jumbo Snow Crab LegsUSD 27.95
Broiled Fillet of SoleUSD 19.95
Broiled Blue FishUSD 17.95
Fresh Broiled HalibutUSD 23.95
Baked SalmonUSD 22.95
Broiled Sea ScallopsUSD 24.95
Broiled Red SnapperUSD 27.95
Broiled Lobster TailUSD 22.95
Broiled Seafood ComboUSD 29.95
Chicken FingersUSD 14.95
Barbecue ChickenUSD 14.95
Baby Back Ribs (Pork)USD 14.95
BBQ Chicken & Ribs (Pork)USD 17.95
Prime RibUSD 21.95
Maryland Lump Crab CakesUSD 28.95
TilapiaUSD 23.95
Shrimp ParmigianaUSD 19.95
Chicken ParmigianaUSD 18.95
Buffalo WingsUSD 13.95
Sandwich Platters
sandwiches served w/ coleslaw & fries
Traditional New England Split Open Lobster RollUSD 24.95
served with coleslaw, chips & pickle
Cajun CatfishUSD 19.95
served with lettuce, tomatoes and Russian dressing
Cabo Fish TacosUSD 19.95
A Baja specialty, two flour tortillas stuffed with beer battered fried cod or haddock, cabbage, tomato, avocado, mixed cheeses and finished with our white cilantro sauce
Salads
Grilled Shrimp Caesar SaladUSD 17.95
Chicken Caesar SaladUSD 15.95
Sammy's Lobster Special
Sammy's Lobster SpecialUSD 19.95
Whole 1-1/4 lb. Maine Lobster; Broiled or Steamed
Pastas for Lunch
Shrimp in Red or Garlic SauceUSD 19.95
Pasta with Red or White Clam SauceUSD 18.95
Sirloin Burgers Platters 8oz.
All of our Sirloin Burgers are served with French Fries, Lettuce & Tomato, Homemade Cole Slaw & Pickle. Toppings: Cheese, Bacon, Mushrooms, Onion Rings, Italian Sauce & Mozzarella or Avocado. Each topping $1 extra
Sirloin BurgerUSD 10.95
CheeseburgerUSD 11.95
Mushroom BurgerUSD 12.95
BBQ BurgerUSD 10.95
Cajun BurgerUSD 10.95
Bacon CheeseburgerUSD 13.95
Seafood Chiller Platter
Seafood Chiller PlatterUSD 28.95
A Great Lobster Combo Lunch Special! 1/2 Maine Lobster with 4 - Shrimp Cocktail, 3 Raw Clams and 3 Raw Fresh Oysters all over ice
Children's Menu
For children under 12-years of age, absolutely no exceptions. Thank you. All of our childrens orders come with French Fries or Baked Potato. Enjoy! All Children's dinners are served with ice cream
Fried ShrimpUSD 14.95
Basket of Chicken FingersUSD 8.95
Hamburger PlatterUSD 9.95
Macaroni & CheeseUSD 9.95
Hot DogsUSD 7.95
Fried ChickenUSD 9.95
Pasta w/ Marinara SauceUSD 7.95
Rack of Baby Back Ribs (Pork)USD 13.95
English Fish & ChipsUSD 12.95
Desserts, Sodas, Coffee & Tea
Child Drink your choice - $1.50
Desserts
Mile High Chocolate Fudge CakeUSD 7.95
Special Tall Cheese CakeUSD 7.95
Mile High 24-Carrot Layer CakeUSD 7.95
Strawberry Short CakeUSD 5.95
Chocolate Mousse CakeUSD 7.95
Red Velvet CakeUSD 7.95
Sammy's TiramisuUSD 7.95
Soft Ice CreamUSD 3.95
Vanilla or Chocolate; cone or dish
TortufoUSD 5.95
Orange or Coconut SorbetUSD 5.95
Lemon or Pineapple SorbetUSD 5.95
FlanUSD 6.95
Tres LechesUSD 6.95
Soft Drinks
$2.95
Coca Cola
Diet Coke
7-Up
Fanta Orange
Lemonade & Fanta Ginger Ale
Iced Tea
$2.95
Black Sweet Tea
Black Unsweetened & Raspberry Tea
Juices
$3
Cranberry
Orange Juice
Grape Fruit Juice
Pineapple Juice
Apple Juice & Homemade Fruit Punch
Coffee
Iced CoffeeUSD 3.00
CappuccinoUSD 4.95
EspressoUSD 3.95
MilkUSD 2.95
Coffee or TeaUSD 1.95
Reg. or Decaf
Specialty Coffees
An Irish KissUSD 6.95
Baileys Irish Cream, Kahlua, Columbian coffee, topped with whipped cream
Caribbean CoffeeUSD 6.95
Dark Rum, Coffee & Whipped cream
Spanish CoffeeUSD 6.95
Tia Maria, coffee liqueur, rum, coffee & whipped cream
Puerto Rican CoffeeUSD 6.95
Captain Morgan Original spiced rum, kahlua, coffee & whipped cream
New York CoffeeUSD 6.95
1 oz white creme de cacao & 1 oz brandy
Bavarian CoffeeUSD 6.95
Peppermint schnapps, Kahlua coffee liquer, coffee & whipped cream
Capt Jacks CoffeeUSD 6.95
Dark rum, Kahlua coffee liqueur, hot coffee, & whipped cream
EspressoUSD 3.95
What 185 people are saying
Overall ratings and reviews
Reviews can only be made by diners who have eaten at this restaurant
- 4.3Food
- 4.2Service
- 4.1Ambience
- 4.1Value
Noise • Moderate
- OT
OpenTable Diner
New York City
3 reviews
5.03 reviews
Dined on 8 September 2024
- Overall 5
- Food 5
- Service 5
- Ambience 5
Staff very friendly and attentive to our needs. Were able to answer any questions and concerns we had.Is this helpful?
- OT
OpenTable Diner
New York City
1 review
5.01 review
Dined on 7 July 2024
- Overall 5
- Food 5
- Service 4
- Ambience 5
It was great I had an amazing birthday celebration there with amazing food 🥹🥰Is this helpful?
- OT
OpenTable Diner
New York City
1 review
5.01 review
Dined on 14 April 2024
- Overall 5
- Food 5
- Service 4
- Ambience 5
Food was delicious and the drink were also very good. Service was amazing! Our server was friendly and always one step ahead. Sammy’s never disappoints!Is this helpful?
- m
monique
New York City
vip34 reviews
5.034 reviews
Dined on 17 February 2024
- Overall 5
- Food 5
- Service 5
- Ambience 5
Great fresh food! Seafood is so delicious!! 😋 I will definitely be back soonIs this helpful?
- BB
BethB
New York City
vip34 reviews
5.034 reviews
Dined on 9 December 2023
- Overall 5
- Food 5
- Service 5
- Ambience 5
Food, drinks, and service were all great. I hadn’t been here in years, and it was as good as I remembered. It definitely did not disappoint. Looking forward to returning soon!Is this helpful?
- C
Curtis
New York City
6 reviews
5.06 reviews
Dined on 4 November 2023
- Overall 5
- Food 4
- Service 5
- Ambience 5
Food was great and the atmosphere was nice. Bonus…free valet parking.Is this helpful?
- SB
SBXINTHN
New York City
9 reviews
5.09 reviews
Dined on 30 September 2023
- Overall 5
- Food 5
- Service 5
- Ambience 5
Easy parking (valet), fast service, really good food, big portions, live DJ with really good music, great vibe that had customers dancing. Highly recommend.Is this helpful?
- M
Memorable
New York City
42 reviews
4.042 reviews
Dined on 2 September 2023
- Overall 4
- Food 4
- Service 4
- Ambience 4
It's an excellent spot for lunch, dinner, date night, and large groups. If you are a seafood lover, Sammy's Shrimp Box is the place. Good service!Is this helpful?
- RL
RachelL
New York City
vip69 reviews
5.069 reviews
Dined on 2 September 2023
- Overall 5
- Food 5
- Service 5
- Ambience 5
The food was amazing !!! The drinks were even better. I always enjoy coming to Sammy’sIs this helpful?
- OT
OpenTable Diner
New York City
5 reviews
5.05 reviews
Dined on 6 August 2023
- Overall 5
- Food 5
- Service 5
- Ambience 5
Food was delicious. Service was very good. Food was fresh and came out quickly. Our waiter was very attentive. They made our family outing perfect. Is this helpful?
FAQs
Sammy's Shrimp Box does offer delivery in partnership with Chow Now.
Sammy's Shrimp Box is rated 4.3 stars by 185 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable.
Make a booking
Order delivery or takeout
64 City Island Avenue, Bronx, NY 10464
Additional information
- AreaCity Island
- Price$30 and under
- CuisinesSeafood, Italian, Spanish
- Dining styleCasual Dining
- Dress codeCasual Dress
- Parking detailsNone
- Phone number(718) 885-3200