Best American Restaurants in Siesta Key
Price
- $40 and under
- $41 to $70
- $71 and over
Regions
Areas
Top Rated
Dining Options
Seating Options
Accessibility
44 restaurants available nearby
How is content generated
See what locals rave about
- JJessVIPHawaii •19 reviews5.0Dined 1 day agoFirst visit to Sarasota- we frequent the Fort Myers location more often. Pleasantly surprised by the elevated experience. Haley- our waitress was polite, prompt, friendly - flawless. The food was perfect - an issue we seem to have in FM with undercooked filet was not an issue here. We ordered medium and got medium. Wine selection was good; margaritas were awesome. Would like to see an expended red wine list with Paso Robles wines someday but still good choices imo. Overall a wonderful night and a great experience. Would go back if in this area again.More infoConnors Steak & Seafood - SarasotaPrice: Expensive• Steakhouse• Siesta Key•4.7
- BBarronVIPNew Orleans / Louisiana •12 reviews5.0Dined 1 day agoThis was a special evening for Valentine's Day with a prix fixe menu. Each dish was wonderfully prepared with the exquisite desserts by Pastry Chef Stephanie Boswell and Chef Erik Walker knows how to make a short rib like no one else. The restaurant continues to impress and we love going here.More infoArts & CentralPrice: Moderate• American• Sarasota•4.7
- TTonyTampa / Central Florida West •12 reviews5.0Dined 2 days agoOur go-to place for special occasions (last night Valentines) so we’re very fond of this quaint restaurant in downtown Sarasota except last night it was so busy that some items seemed to have slipped through the cracks. The food is always great however last night wasn’t as great. The service was excellent for us but we noticed other tables were not as fortunate. The prices seemed to have been adjusted for the Valentine’s menu (adjusted meaning RAISED), for we each had a meal, (Grouper / Pork Oso-busco) nothing fancy) a glass of wine and shared a dessert with one complimentary basket of bread (NOT even a house salad) and the bill was $175! A bit pricey if you’d ask me.More infoThe Rosemary & ThymePrice: Expensive• American• Sarasota•4.8
- CCheryl and HankVIPToledo / Northwest Ohio •33 reviews5.0Dined 3 days agoFood was absolutely delicious!! I had the Chicken Milanese and loved it- topped off with a decadent key lime pie!More infoLibby's - SarasotaPrice: Moderate• Contemporary American• Sarasota•4.7
- VVerniceVIPSan Francisco Bay Area •33 reviews5.0Dined 3 days agoWe dined on the outside - the street tables set up to accommodate all the Valentines diners and it worked out perfectly. Although very busy we were waited on by David reasonably fast. The food was fantastic. With all the activity in Sarasota we joked we got dinner and a show (some pedestrians were quite amusing) at HP Always a treat and never disappointed ❤️More infoHyde Park Prime Steakhouse - SarasotaPrice: Expensive• Steakhouse• Sarasota•4.7
Discover best American restaurants in Siesta Key
Discover the vibrant American dining scene in Siesta Key, Tampa / Central Florida West, Sarasota / Bradenton, where you can indulge in a variety of American cuisine options. Whether you're craving juicy steaks, fresh seafood, gourmet salads, or hearty pastas, the area's restaurants cater to every taste with high-quality ingredients and expert preparation. Enjoy the relaxed yet sophisticated atmosphere that characterizes many of these establishments, ideal for both casual and formal dining experiences. Patrons consistently praise the attentive service and the consistently delicious food, indicating a commitment to excellence across these dining venues. Each restaurant in this locale strives to provide a memorable culinary adventure, emphasizing the importance of a satisfying dining experience. This area is a must-visit for food enthusiasts and anyone looking to savor the best of American cuisine in a beautiful coastal setting.