Best American Restaurants in Smithfield

It’s my wife and I second time at the Vintage tavern and it didn’t disappoint. We really like the cabin vibe. The food is fantastic with so many unique dishes. I opted for the lamb chops special. My wife and daughter had the duck and her boyfriend had the beef tenderloin. All were very tasty and perfectly cooked. We opened with the pimento cheese and I had an old fashioned that was excellent. We will definitely be back again.

Everything was great, wish we could afford to go more often.

We enjoyed celebrating our 46 wedding anniversary. The crab cakes were the largest and nicest I’ve ever eaten. The trout had a little more breading than he liked. The sweet potato muffins were perfection. The Irish flute entertainment was very enjoyable. Dining by candlelight was very romantic. This is an historic building and is not handicapped friendly. The restroom is downstairs. Parking is in the back and where you enter the drive is not obvious and down the street—hard to see after dark. The menu is historic style and fun to read. We love to eat here on every visit to Colonial Williamsburg. I make reservations several months in advance.

Our meal at the King's Arms Tavern was one of the absolute highlights of our visit to Williamsburg. The food was unbelievable, the service was lovely, and we enjoyed the live harpist who played for a bit. Cannot wait to return!

Valentines menu was great, tasty, good value, thoroughly enjoyable evening.