Best Steakhouses in Cold Spring Harbor

Gorgeous space. Excellent cocktails and food. The server Kathy and hostess team lead by Jocelyn were so great! We will definitely be back to try more items on the menu. Great restaurant for date night, girls night or a special occasion. We also were guests of the hotel and it was a great overall time.

Another fabulous evening at Rothmann’s. There’s a reason we keep coming back, the ambiance, the warm welcome, the service, the amazing food…it all makes it worthwhile. As soon as you walk in you are welcomed by Jon and Benoit. You need to visit master mixologist, Alejandro at the bar for a perfect drink before your dinner. Now I may be biased but after years of coming to Rothmann’s we do have our favorites, food and staff members. We always request to be seated with Keith and Giovanni. They will make your evening a memorable one. Don’t forget to order the seafood platter, a must for seafood lovers. The filet mignon is always cooked to perfection. Don’t forget to finish your meal with an affogato, you won’t regret it.

First time, long time for brunch here. Usually just come for dinner. Brunch was off the charts excellent. Had a variety of different items, all really good. The banana Nutella pancakes were terrific.... Will definitely have again. Omlette was great as well. Also liked that some of the basic menu was available for those that don't like brunch food.

even though it was valentine’s day at 9:30 pm, the crew held it together considering there was a mildly unruly crowd of people at the entrance waiting to check in/be called to be seated. my reservation was at 9:30 and we only waited about 25 minutes (i’ve waited longer for worse) sat us promptly in excellent seats and immediately had the wine list ready for us to order. the calm demeanor of the staff was very comforting considering how absolutely bustling it was. it was my first experience here and i can say i’m very impressed by the service and the selections at the center ‘market table’*. countless choices of italian meats, cheeses, vegetables.. etc. although i couldn’t see any bowls for the soup, i was more than satisfied with the rest of the choices available. every meat in styles you would never think of were waltzed around the entire seating area, of which my date and i sampled all. the lamb steak was seasoned and cooked perfectly, you can absolutely taste the flavors of the meat itself without it being overpowered by seasoning, probably our joint favorite. although the filet mignon was a bit dry and overdone, it was small potatoes compared to every other selection of meat that emerged upon our table. each member of staff was very polite once again with the preponderance of meat selections. a side of mashed potatoes and two sides of pão de queijo were delivered with no request. overall i’ll give it an 8.1/10. guaranteed to make any date night into and extravagant event.

Had a wonderful evening at IMC. The food and even the Toasted Coconut martini from the bar were delish. I had the avocado fritters for appetizer and salmon as my entree. My husband had clams on the 1/2 shell and the ribeye and that was also phenomenal. The service was excellent and we are looking forward to going back.