Best Sicilian Restaurants in Atlantic Highlands

The food was excellent. We ordered fried calamari and rice balls as appetizers and both were great. I ordered chicken Marsala and my husband ordered Shrimp Fra Diavolo. Both dishes were excellent. Our servers were very good, but I rated them a 4 because no one came by to ask if we wanted coffee or dessert. Our reservations were for 7:30 and we left the restaurant at 10:00 - no one rushed us out, but that said, I’m sure we were sitting for 30 - 45 min with no one coming by except those who cleared our table. In fact, we had to ask for the check. While I loved the selection of music they played, but it was a tad loud. We may have been sitting under a speaker. The bottom line is that overall it was a great restaurant with outstanding food and very good service. We will definitely be back.

Great quality - neighborhood spot vibe. Prices are a little high.

Great neighborhood spot that we travel to form a different neighborhood. We loved this space when it was Prime Meats and are happy that they have kept the interior largely intact. Pizza was delicious as were the drinks and apps we ordered. The service was lovely and the general vibe was buzzy but relaxed. Am already looking forward to our next visit.

Great experience. Good service, food and friendly owners. Will be back.