Best Historic Restaurants in Yamacraw Village

We were promptly greeted by the hostess and seated before our reservation time. Our server, Hannah(sp?), was fantastic. She provided very detailed descriptions of the wine, specials, and food offerings. She was attentive, but not annoying. Her enthusiasm was refreshing. She was quick to clear our table, when needed. Hannah was very personable and friendly, while remaining the consummate professional, which my husband and I truly appreciated. Our meals, from the appetizers to desserts, were phenomenal. The Chef and his team prepared and presented, in our opinion, Michelin and James Beard quality everything. While the price points are high compared to other restaurants in the Savannah area, Alligator Soul is worth it. Especially because the offerings are exotic and unique, but still “familiar.” We have dined here a few times over the years, pre-Covid. The dining experience is just as exceptional this visit as it had been in the past. We highly recommend Alligator Soul because of the Chef, the Sommalier, and Hannah, our server.

Second time visiting this amazing restaurant. Was so amazing the first time had to come back. And they did not disappoint. Love the intimacy and how small the place is so it's not loud even with the tables being semi close. Great customer service as always sat right away even though we were 10min early to our reservation. Got the NY Striptease which was made perfectly medium rare. With some potato puree and green beans. VERY good sized steak at least 16oz, only ate half of it and brought the rest home. Friend had the catch of the day and she said it was absolutely amazing. May be on the pricier side but the service and food quality makes it absolutely worth the price.

The Fettuccine Carbonara was amazing, great deal with much food to spare! The Crispy Pancetta was cooked to perfection

Wonderful ambiance. Christmas lights and a warm cozy feeling. I had the Lobster Rabini and it was delicious. My brother had the Carbonara and it to was delicious. It’s really wonderful and relaxing. Our server Taylor was very attentive and we enjoyed talking to her.

Always a great time, exceptional service. Food and drinks were amazing, fresh and so yummy