Best Italian Restaurants in Shelter Island / San Diego Bay

Amazing food in a great place! Will absolutely return

The food, service and atmosphere were all wonderful. Stefano was our server and he was amazing! They were able to accommodate a simple cheese pizza for our kids, Stefano provided an exceptional wine pairing recommendation, and overall a great experience. Can’t wait to return.

Amazing staff and food that’s to die for. I love italian food and this is by FAR my favorite Italian restaurant! Taste remains the same each visit. I leave satisfied and happy each time!!!🩷 I hope they continue to thrive and stay in business for a long time. I CANNOT RAVE ENOUGH ABOUT THE COMPLEMENTARY BREAD 😋😋 -The pasta straws are super adorable and innovative !

We had a lovely new years brunch (though I do wish they actually served brunch fare). Everything was very delicious! The service, while very friendly and accommodating, got a little slow toward the end as it got busier, which is understandable. It would’ve been okay except we were in a booth that was one of two they have for parties of six but maybe six short, slim people? Pretty uncomfortable, especially in that corner spot, I spent the whole meal with my arms up over the back of the booth. I’m chubby but the rest of my party were regular sized men and one slim woman and we all felt squashed. But otherwise, a beautiful meal on a lovely day.

It’s was exciting to still catch holidays decorated indoors and outdoor. Food is great! We’ve had HALIBUT PUTTANESCA entree, MISO POMODORO pasta, WOOD FIRED BRUSSELS SPROUTS as shared. Big plus is that they still have seasonal cocktails. Our waitress didn’t offer us any water, but it’s was something we didn’t notice until the end. No a big deal. 10/10 in overall