Best Historic Restaurants in Milton

This experience was absolutely amazing and worth every penny! The menu had great options, the waiter Reid was fantastic with his great recommendations and service, the atmosphere was quiet and elegant. Me and my date was just amazed at everything. The one downside was the bathrooms which could have been cleaner but other than that the entire night was memorable. Shout out the staff, management and of course the beautiful hands that prepared our meals.

Jennifer was awesome again, and her suggestions were spot on! Had the special, steak, and shrimp with "cowboy butter," WOW, so good. She was even able to substitute shrimp for scallops for my partner. I absolutely love everything about this restaurant! Front door, Bar, and wait staff are incredible!! The food is excellent! Jennifer, we will see you again soon!!

Outstanding Italian Dining Experience at Osteria Mattone We had an incredible Valentine’s Day dinner at Osteria Mattone, and everything—from the food to the service—was exceptional. We started with the Arancini Carbonara and burrata, both of which were excellent choices with rich, delicious flavors. The cocktails, Dark Manhattan and Om Old Fashioned, were simply outstanding. For our mains, we enjoyed the Cacio e Pepe pasta with Salmone, which was beautifully presented and packed with amazing flavors. The Branzino was equally impressive—perfectly cooked and full of taste. To finish, the Budino Caramellato was the perfect sweet ending, absolutely delicious. The ambiance was just right for a special evening—warm, inviting, and intimate. A special mention to Michaela, who provided top-notch service, recommending most of our dishes, all of which were spot on. Overall, Osteria Mattone exceeded our expectations, and we’ll definitely be coming back. Highly recommend for anyone looking for authentic Italian cuisine with impeccable service!

I made the ressy for Valentines Day back in early January and I am glad I did as it was packed. There were people still coming in at 930 when we left. We were seated at a cozy table. The waiter was very attentive and on the ball. We ordered the calamari appetizer which was nice and crispy. My wife had the airline chicken which she loved. Moist, tender and the veggies accompanying it were delicious. She said it was the best restaurant chicken she ever had. I had the lobster and shrimp pasta over their homemade spaghetti which did not skimp on shell fish. A very good value for both dishes. We finished the meal with a rum cake desert which was not overly sweet; just the way it should be. We were looking forward to the branzino but with it being a special Valentines menu we will have to come back to that. We left very satisfied!

Casual meets luxury at this Tavern! The cocktails were superb. We had the spiked lemonade and it was delicious! The burgers are fresh and cooked perfectly. The wait staff was attentive, warm and inviting. We were not rushed through dinner or made to feel we were taking up space. The atmosphere is fun and energetic but not so loud that you can’t enjoy great conversation. All around loved the vibe! We will definitely be back.