Best Steak Restaurants in Bayville

This is our favorite steakhouse on Long Island! We always come here ! The service is exceptional, classy and such an amazing ambiance! Our son Al comes her all the time as well! The food is delicious and cooked to perfection!their drinks are of high quality and very strong!

This was our first time visiting Prime for my wife’s birthday and honestly we had a fantastic experience. As a “chef” by trade and being in the culinary industry for close to 15 years, i haven’t been that happy with spending what i did on food in a long time. My wife order the New York Strip med rare with a side of Mac and Cheese. The age on it was great. Not to nutty and funky that it’s a turn off for the majority of people, but not so mild that I questioned if it was actually aged. The Mac was perfect. I could eat it every day. I ordered the Half Chicken to try something different than I normally do. Hands down, best chicken and grits I have ever had from a restaurant. The Chicken was perfectly cooked yet the skin was just ever so perfectly golden and crisp, not charred like most places would make it. I suspect it’s a salt cure with some weight on it, but regardless how it’s done it’s amazing. I can’t wait to come back again!

The igloo is a very cool experience. On top of that the food was very very good. 10/10 recommend if you are looking for a more intimate date night with exceptional service.

My young kids and I took my wife here for her birthday. Service was great, décor was charming, and food was delicious. We'll definitely be back.

I went to an early Valentine’s Day dinner with friends, and it was truly a memorable experience. The atmosphere was enchanting, with soft candlelight flickering on the tables and gentle music playing in the background. Each dish we savored was a culinary masterpiece, beautifully presented and bursting with flavor. The highlight of the evening was definitely the exceptional service provided by the manager, Cliff, who went above and beyond to ensure we had a fantastic time. His warm hospitality and attention to detail made the night even more special.