Best Live Music Restaurants in New Albany

Lexi was our server and she was amazing, super nice and we have the same name so 1000 aura points. She was very attentive, knew the menu well and gave great suggestions (stuffed jumbo shrimp). The food was perfect, overall 10/10 experience. Very blessed I had the chance to dine here for Valentines weekend.

Ate there for Valentine's Day 2025 with wife, server was Chris R. (attentive & knowledgeable, checked back with us frequently). Menu was nice, with a specials add-on (Exec Chef & Sous Chef may be related). We chose salads, followed by a strip steak for me and chilean sea bass for wife. Boxed and took home leftovers plus desserts (limoncello chesecake, chocolate cake). Our terrier loved some of the leftovers, too (especially steak, risotto)!! Good value, high quality food

Valentines date, thank you for making it amazing!!! Every little touch you guys did for the special date night was wonderful.

If things did not cost money, I would fly my hover car from my Malibu beach house to Mastro’s Columbus every day. Even taking the world as it is, I will need to go back soon. Mastro’s just opened in Columbus, and it truly seems like Rome was built there in a day. The service my wife and I received was unparalleled. From the Moment Nathan brought us to our table, to the moment Izzy picked up our plates, I felt not only the satisfaction of being cared for by the highest category of professionals, but that I was in the company of people who were genuinely invested in making sure we had the most romantic dinner possible. The head of the show was our waiter Christian, who couldnt have treated us better if we were his own family. He gave us recommendations, introduced us to the chef, and at the end of the evening, even gave us a complimentary dessert, which spelled out the occasion we were celebrating in chocolate letters. This is an establishment where the only thing as incredible as the food is the staff’s dedication to radical hospitality. I couldn’t recommend it more highly, and if your night is even half as special as Christian made ours — you’ll never ever forget it. -Will Stryker

Love the new bar area - although it is too loud and hard to hear the bands play. It would be nice if you could add some sound absorption material in the room. Maybe some speakers distributed at a lower volume in the room would be helpful.