Best Neighbourhood Gem Restaurants in Pewaukee

My wife and I have been at ID a few times and have always had a great experience. We like to try different spots but nothing really compares to ID. The food is fresh and unique and full of flavor. The craft cocktails are really fun to try and the staff seems to enjoy what they do. We woke up this morning talking about the short rib tacos…we’ll be back for those real soon….cheers!

Great experience. Jenna C was so friendly and efficient. Crab cakes, yummy. The rack of lamb was very good, seasoned well, but one chop was too fatty with little lamb meat. The pistachio cheese cake is so good. Will be back!!!

Wonderful layers of flavor, welcoming staff, time with the lake.

We had an outstanding first experience at the Red Circle Inn last night for my wife's birthday. I would classify this restaurant as a historic fine-dining supper club. The staff were wonderful and the restaurant was beautifully decorated and clean. They even hand-wrote a card for my wife's birthday and the servers all signed it and had it all displayed on the table before we even arrived. We had the walleye, perch, and beef stroganoff with cheese curds and French onion soup appetizers. There was even a relish tray with sourdough crackers, cheese spread, olives, and peppers. It was all very delicious. In summary, I would highly recommend this restaurant if you want an elevated dining experience with a supper club feel.

Great Experience. Nancy and Jeff were Fantastic, checked in on us regularly, making sure everything was to our satisfaction. Food was excellent, steaks cooked to our individual speciations and side dishes were a nice compliment to our meal. Will Definitely be going back!!!