Best Historic Restaurants in Whitefish Bay

Second time I’ve eaten at Onesto. Still very tasty and enjoyable experience. Love the care and quality put in the food. Good service. Enjoyable ambience. Reasonable prices for the quality. Love that even on the second visit I already had discounts by being in the Loyalty Program.

No contest, best Italian in the city! Impossible to pick just one favorite item on the menu!

Tre Rivila exceeded all expectations during my recent visit! From the moment I walked in, the atmosphere was welcoming and elegant. Our server, Mimi, was absolutely phenomenal. She was attentive, friendly, and made excellent recommendations that truly elevated our dining experience. The food was exceptional—perfectly prepared and bursting with flavor. Thank you, Tre Rivila, and a special shoutout to Mimi for her outstanding service. We’ll definitely be back and highly recommend this gem to anyone looking for an unforgettable dining experience!

Wow, what an awesome experience!!! Had the seasonal tasting which was a pricey experience but an experience that cannot compare to most others. This restaurant is a quaint place with some amazing waitstaff. We must have had a rotation of at least 5 servers bringing drinks, clearing courses, setting up new courses, serving & explaining each course and simply catering to any request we had. The flow was spot on. The food was unreal & impossible for me to describe with it's complexities. Each course was unique in a way that I've never had & I've eaten at Michelin Stars in Paris. Chef & team obviously take much pride in their creativity & amazing quality. Truly 1 of my top 5 food experiences in my 68 years! Can't wait for my next visit.

Went to celebrate a birthday. Cute birthday card on the table! Service was above and beyond. We had a soy allergy in the group and the waiter - David?- was so helpful to make sure nothing was cross contaminated and brought separate appetizers to be sure she could have a taste of the wagu pastry. A bit disappointed the cauliflower steak and curry scallops were no long on the menu but we found great alternatives. Favorites were cacio e Pepe, shrimp and grits, and tuna - ask for dressing on the side. Lively atmosphere. One of our favorite Milwaukee restaurants and would highly recommend!