Best Historic Restaurants in Bayville

Cozy atmosphere . Excellent food with good variety. Always a good experience. Had beet salad and seared Ahi tuna . Both excellent.

The food is consistently great, and there is an excellent selection. The ambiance is nice and friendly, and the service is first-class. It's the perfect spot for an enjoyable evening and great food.

The Wednesday prie fix menu is a good deal 3 courses $29 Of course if you have drinks/wine it’s more but overall a great deal

I saw lots of bad reviews and was nervous, but if you're prepared to wait an extra 30-45 minutes from your reservation time, it's worth it. I'd never been here, but I think the delays are from the holiday rush. We waited about 40 minutes from our reservation time to get a table. But this gave us the time to walk around the winter village which is beautiful. So if you don't have to be seated immediately, I'd highly recommend it. Also, the food takes time, too. I don't remember exactly how long to get our plates, but longer than usual. It's expensive, but you're paying for the ambience, the experience and the food is pretty good. Not the best food in the world, but we really enjoyed it. And the Christmas Carolers sung beautiful Christmas songs all around the restaurant. So be ready to break the bank, wait a little longer, but get a unique holiday experience while doing so.

Wow. The atmosphere is incredible and it truly feels like nothing else on Long Island. The servers are very knowledgeable and helped us pick an amazing wine (get the Cain, you won’t be disappointed). The meal was a whole other experience with some of the best plates we’ve had. Highly recommend ordering a bunch of stuff to share- we loved the raviolo, pork sticky ribs, the carrots and the radicchio salad. Thank you to the whole team for making our evening so special!!