Best Vegan Restaurants in Fire Island

Mashed potatoes were very bland and porterhouse was not as seasoned as I would have liked but the Mac and cheese and ribeye were amazing. Great cocktails too and excellent service. Bathrooms also needed to be cleaned, not great in there.

We had a perfect birthday celebration in this restaurant. Everything was superb, including the band that played live music.

Warm welcoming staff, great atmosphere and delicious food and cocktails.

I was looking for a nice place to take my sister and her husband. This place did not disappoint. The ambience was beautiful. The waiter was amazing. Since we were new to ITA kitchen, he explained everything on the menu with ease and answered all of our questions. The food was delicious. I will be returning to this place for dinner well worth my money and time.

We have been to Painters many times and will continue to come back. The staff are always genuinely nice and, in our experience, very hard working (today our server was Amanda). We appreciate the wide variety of food options and we always enjoy our meal (today was the Mediterranean omelette). A friend who we treated to lunch thought her hamburger was the best she ever had; my personal favorite is the Orange Pecan French Toast. It is perfect for any occasion and it is not unusual for someone to be celebrating a baby shower or birthday in the back area. The atmosphere is always comfortable and casual, and the large parking lot is a nice bonus.