Best Restaurants with a Tasting Menu in City Island

Price

$$
$$$
$$$$

Cuisine

AmericanItalianSteakhouseSeafoodMexicanJapanese

Regions

BergenManhattanNassauQueensWestchester

Areas

AstoriaBaysideFlushingFort LeeGlen CoveHarlem

Top Rated

CharmingFancyGood for business mealsGood for groupsGood for special occasionsGreat for brunch

Dining Options

All dining options

Delivery only

Takeaway only

Seating Options

BarCounterStandardHigh TopOutdoor

Accessibility

Gender-neutral restroomWheelchair access

11 restaurants available nearby

1. NoMa Social

4.3

Awesome(332)

$$$$Price: Moderate

• Mediterranean • New Rochelle

Booked 1 time today

Serving up small plates such as haloumi a la plancha with fig jam, cioppolini onion candy, and skirt steak to name a few from our long tapas list at NoMa Social located in the Hotel NoMa. The dinner menu offers such items as wood-fired pizzas, paella, chicken scarpariello, and custom charcuterie boards. The restaurant also features an extensive wine and beer menu, along with signature sangrias. The scene is set for guests to enjoy our tempting menu in a chic atmosphere, casually and comfortably. NoMa Social is a local favorite for lunch and dinner, playing host to neighborhood foodies and hotel guests alike. Offering daily specials and late night, weekend menus. Whether sitting at our bar or in the dining room, or one of our comfortable couches, our delicious menu has something for everyone.

A photo of Il Mulino New York - Long Island restaurant

2. Il Mulino New York - Long Island

4.6

Exceptional(1548)

$$$$Price: Very Expensive

• Italian • Roslyn

Booked 15 times today

Gather your friends and family for an unforgettable evening. Nestled in the vibrant North Shore, indulge in a delightful night where every bite is a celebration of flavors and every moment is cherished. Experience the finest ingredients and unforgettable flavors of Manhattan at our Long Island outpost. Zagat has rated Il Mulino New York as Manhattan’s No. 1 Italian restaurant for decades and has said the restaurant provides "one-of-a-kind" cuisine filled with delicious flavors, creating an "outstanding Italian classic" restaurant where "every dish is a masterpiece." Executive Chef Michele Mazza, who hails from Naples, Italy, has proudly carried this tradition since 2003. Fresh ingredients, artistic preparation and impeccable service distinguish Il Mulino New York as one of the world’s premiere restaurants. In addition to fine dining, Il Mulino New York provides excellent off-site catering and products.

3. Masaaki

4.8

Exceptional(196)

$$$$Price: Expensive

• Japanese • Bayside

Booked 3 times today

Dear customers:Omakase Bar seating: $98 per person will be 15 courses, $138 per person will be 18 courses.Table Tasting Menu (not on bar): $88 per person will be 15 courses.Our Omakase reservation is available for four rounds each day: 1pm/5pm/6:30pm/8pm,each round will be one hour and half.If you want to reserve an Omakase bar seating, please go to the "experience" section and select the time slots that you would like to reserve (1pm/5pm/6:30pm/8pm),which will be the only reservation for our Omakase bar seating.All other reservations will be for our regular dine in table/ regular table Omakase tasting menu. Please double check before making reservations.We will be communicating through SMS and/or e-mail with customers about their opentable reservation, so please make sure that either the phone number or the e-mail address is correct when you make the reservation.Masaaki management team.

4. Kaizen Flushing

4.9

Exceptional(129)

$$$$Price: Very Expensive

• Sushi • Flushing

Booked 6 times today

**To reserve a seat for our exclusive 15-course omakase experience at the sushi counter, please select the "Experiences" option below and book under 15-Course Omakase.Discover Kaizen, where tradition meets innovation in the heart of Flushing, Queens. Our menu, featuring premium sushi, sashimi, and hand rolls, celebrates the art of Japanese cuisine with a modern twist, offering flavors that are both timeless and inspired. Whether you're indulging in our exquisite 15-course omakase or sharing small plates with friends, every dish is crafted to excite the palate and elevate the moment. With a vibrant atmosphere perfect for social occasions, corporate events, or intimate gatherings, Kaizen promises a dining experience that’s as dynamic and delightful as its name suggests.Important: The sushi counter is only reserved for omakase.

A photo of Sushi Kai - Fort Lee restaurant

5. Sushi Kai - Fort Lee

4.7

Exceptional(165)

$$$$Price: Very Expensive

• Sushi • Fort Lee

Booked 7 times today

ATTENTION: We need 48 hours' notice of any allergies/dietary restrictions to ensure we can accommodate. We are unable to do so the day of. Thank you! Sushi Kai prides itself on offering a daily tasting menu, highlighting fresh and seasonal ingredients right in the heart of Fort Lee, NJ. Have a seat at our sushi counter and let our chef’s showcase their passion for a memorable omakase experience.Our Omakase experience is $155/person. This will include a multi course seasonal tasting menu, including appetizers, sashimi, nigiri and dessert. Seating's are strictly 2 hours with seating at the bar only. Please note we do have a 48-hour cancellation policy. Any cancellations made within that timeframe are subject to a $155.00 per person fee. This is non-refundable & non-negotiable. Please be aware we do allow BYOB of all types of alcohol with no corkage fee.

6. Blend Astoria

4.5

Awesome(849)

$$$$Price: Expensive

• Latin / Spanish • Astoria

Booked 18 times today

Welcome to Blend, where the flavors of Latin Fusion come to life in an enchanting setting. With an enticing array of dishes thoughtfully crafted to satisfy any appetite, we elevate Latin cuisine to new heights. Indulge in our stunning and inviting ambiance, where every visit is destined to become a cherished memory.

7. Lido

4.7

Exceptional(2025)

$$$$Price: Moderate

• Italian • Harlem

Booked 16 times today

Lido’s menu is Northern Italian. The menu can be described as fresh, simple, and delicious. Flavors are layered so that each one stands out but does not compete with others in the dish. The food is organic and local whenever possible and all poultry and meats are from farms that treat animals humanely. The ambiance is modish but relaxed. We look forward to seeing you soon.*For parties of 9 or more, please call the restaurant to reserve.

8. Galo Tavern 18

4.8

Exceptional(570)

$$$$Price: Moderate

• American • New Hyde Park

Booked 3 times today

Welcome to Galo Tavern 18, your neighborhood grill where delicious food meets a warm and welcoming atmosphere! We take pride in serving mouthwatering Continental and American steakhouse cuisine at prices that make dining out a joy. As you step inside, you'll be enchanted by the rich charm of our deep mahogany woodwork, soaring vaulted ceilings, and captivating black-and-white photos of old New York, all creating a cozy and inviting space for everyone.Whether you're eager to cheer on your favorite team with a refreshing craft beer or enjoy a delightful lunch or dinner, we have something special for everyone! Don't forget to treat yourself to our amazing Sunday brunch, which has quickly become a favorite among our guests!

A photo of Otherside Wine Bar restaurant

9. Otherside Wine Bar

4.7

Exceptional(36)

$$$$Price: Moderate

• Wine Bar • Glen Cove

Booked 4 times today

Otherside Wine Bar is here to bring authenticity and soul to the community in Glen Cove and beyond. We focus on natural wines that express the places where they grow and the people who grow them. Our menu is rooted in Mediterranean cooking with an emphasis on local ingredients, featuring finely-tuned small plates meant for sharing and larger portioned entrees and celebrated burgers for those seeking comfort food.Located in the historic JH Coles Homestead, our dining room dates back to 1810—a perfect place to gather and celebrate our community over a meal.

10. Agenda Restaurant

4.1

Excellent(9)

$$$$Price: Moderate

• Latin American • Astoria

Booked 4 times today

Latin Cuisine Restaurant. Bottomless Brunch- Mimosa, Sangria & Margarita! Every Saturday & Sundays 11 am-6pm. Indulge in a delightful Prix Fixe Brunch. Feast on classic American & Latin Dishes; Pancakes, Tres Golpes, Avocado Toast, Steak & Eggs, French Toast to name a few. Top-off your Brunch Experience with an after- Brunch party with vibrant beats of our Live DJ's.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you

M
Marc
New York City •1 review
5.0
Dined 2 days ago
As always amazing experience and food is second to none!
More info
Il Mulino New York - Long IslandPrice: Very Expensive• Italian• Roslyn
•
4.6
J
Jason
New York City •3 reviews
5.0
Dined 3 days ago
This has been my favorite Omakase experience of all. It is a bit pricier than some omakase’s but it is worth the extra money, every single piece was incredible, especially the first dish. Their Valentines special was amazing and I would definitely come back again next year again!
More info
MasaakiPrice: Expensive• Japanese• Bayside
•
4.8
B
Brooklyn
4 reviews
5.0
Dined 7 days ago
Kaizen feels like stepping into a hidden oasis. The lighting is soft, the staff greets you like an old friend, and the chefs move with the precision of artists. Before I even took a bite, I knew I was in for something special
More info
Kaizen FlushingPrice: Very Expensive• Sushi• Flushing
•
4.9
J
jennifer
New York City •1 review
5.0
Dined on 8 Feb 2025
If you are debating on where to eat tonight, don’t think twice just book the reservation. My husband and I have been to the top Omakasa restaurants in NYC and this place tops them all. The food is incredible, the atmosphere is calming, and the service is top notch. I swear that you will be talking about your dinner for weeks to come. You won’t regret it.
More info
Sushi Kai - Fort LeePrice: Very Expensive• Sushi• Fort Lee
•
4.7
K
Kathy
New York State •2 reviews
4.0
Dined on 7 Feb 2025
Always a fun time amazing food,drinks on point severs are amazing to detail. Bartenders rock!
More info
NoMa SocialPrice: Moderate• Mediterranean• New Rochelle
•
4.3

Explore OpenTable

Area
Tasting menu

City Island

Yorkville
Gowanus
Forest Hills
Clinton Hill
Jamaica
Greenpoint
Carroll Gardens
Upper West Side
Flushing
Park Slope
Middle Village
Midtown West
Hell's Kitchen
Astoria
Carnegie Hill
Murray Hill
Woodhaven
Upper East Side
Financial District
Midtown East