Best Restaurants with a Fireplace in Rye

Excellent anniversary meal for the second year in a row. The cocktails are amazing. The duck pie with quince was delicious, as was the parsnip soup, and crispy skin chicken. The chocolate pudding is one of the best desserts ever. There was a kitchen mishap on the scotch egg, but the staff handled it graciously. Wonderful place for a special occasion.

The Atlantic Grill was by far the best restaurant I have been to! From the time we walked through the doors, until our last bite of delicious dessert, we were given a wonderful dining experience. The Atlantic Grill is a must try! You will NOT be disappointed!

Excellent food and service. Our waitress, Sadie, was outstanding, attentive, and friendly. Highly recommend this restaurant.

Always perfect food, service , ambiance, and sure to run into neighborhood friends

The restaurant seemed to cater to an older crowd which wasn't bad since I am in my sixties. We were seated at a table that was very wet. When given a drink minute, there were no prices listed. When I asked the server, he didn't know how much they were and said they varied in price. The food was very good with large portions. The price was average-high being at the beach and in a resort hotel. The fisherman's platter was $28. Enjoyed the DJ and dancing in the rear of the restaurant starting at 8pm. All in all we had a good time and would go back.