Best Restaurants for Foodies in Fisher Island

We had a wonderful experience at Casa Neos but the thing that made the evening so good was absolutely our server Vicky. She is so attentive & made sure every detail was perfect for us. She even adjusted a drink that one of us had to make it perfect! Would go back again and again!

Amazing place! Food was superb and brought me back to Modena dining at Massimo Bottura’s flagship restaurants. Service was impeccable. All servers were warm, friendly and knowledgeable. And the design of the restaurant is so transformative. Will be back often!

Lala’s service at Rusty Pelican was truly unique and exceptional! We enjoyed the sea bass and Atlantic salmon—both were delicious—and the maracuya drink was a standout. Even the kids’ mac and cheese was a hit. Lala’s attentiveness and warm personality made the experience unforgettable. We’ll definitely be back!

This was my second time to Stubborn Seed and it was as wonderful as the first time. The staff went above and beyond to make my experience so special, including making me a sweet paper crane and letting me order some items to go. This is the kind of hospitality that makes lifelong memories. Jackie, Tokyo, and the rest of the team were absolutely fantastic.

I had been wanting to go to Giselle and it was just as I expected. A great place for a date with sexy vibe, entertainment, tasty food and drinks. Service excellent. Just go!!! Had a wonderful night !