Best Restaurants for Birthdays in Shelter Island / San Diego Bay

This is your place if you enjoy authentic Italian made with care and refinement. Best atmosphere and great service. We go for special occasions and when we host people from out of town. Absolutely delish! Regularly exceeds expectations.

Amazing celebration after our wedding. The food is always great and our server, Jessie was cheerful, appreciative of our celebration, brought a mud pie as a wedding cake and genuinely joined in to make our experience so festive and joyful! The bay was beautiful with clear blue skies. It could not have been better. Thank you for helping us celebrate the day.

We were seated promptly in a perfect seat by the window. The brunch was amazing with a wide variety of selections. We tested nearly every item. Lol. 2 hours to enjoy the brunch so we weren’t rushed. Our waitress was attentive and saw to our needs (refilled drinks, water, coffee). This was our first time for the brunch after several dinners. I have no doubt we’ll be back for more brunches.

Everything about the food was excellent including the oysters, the lobster bisque, the Caesar salad and especially the fish and chips. Our drinks were well made and worth the money. The view is amazing and the service is great. Don't miss this experience when you are in San Diego.

Attended the 5-course Christmas Eve dinner. It was worth every penny- from start to finish it was coursed beautifully, ingredients were fresh and cooked perfectly to temp, plating was festive and colourful; and all this with just the right timed check-ins from my bartender/server James. The couple next to me did the wine pairing and everything was explained nicely and paired well... along with some fun history & stories- I opted for the cocktails which were creative and utilized some lovely ingredients as well as being well balanced.