Best Restaurants for Anniversaries in Menomonee Falls

Service was excellent. Our friendly waiter was Tommy and he was great. I had the Perch fish fry and my wife had the lobster tail special for Valentine's Day. Both were great. Looking forward to our next time.

Always a great and memorable dining experience! Service, food, ambiance are all top notch!

My wife and I had a delightful evening at Mr. B’s in Brookfield, celebrating our last Valentine’s Day together as a couple. Since my wife is pregnant, I wanted to do something special and memorable. We had a 5:30 p.m. reservation, but the restaurant was already packed. Despite the wait, which lasted about 10 minutes past our reservation time, we were pleasantly surprised to receive two hors d’oeuvres—bruschetta and bacon—during that period. Once we were seated, we were greeted by two attentive and friendly wait staff members. They kept our water glasses filled throughout the meal, which is a priority for us. We ordered beverages, and they arrived at our table faster than we had ever experienced. As an appetizer, we shared a lobster Mac and cheese, which was both delicious and satisfying. For our main courses, I opted for the 18-ounce ribeye, while my wife chose the 8-ounce filet mignon. Both steaks were cooked to perfection and left us with leftovers that were even better the next day. To end our wonderful evening, we indulged in a decadent crème brûlée. Thank you for providing us with a memorable dining experience. We will definitely be returning to Mr. B’s in the future.

For the price you pay, the service of EVERY hostess and WAIT STAFF needs evaluating. Some are extremely kind, quick to respond and attentive, others unattentive, Luke warm, and slow. Would love to experience consistency of service because I love dining in place..