Best Restaurants with Private Rooms in City Island

It was our second time there in the past week. Hadn’t been there for awhile and went with our friends that never ate there. Everyone loved it and went back last night. Food and service were excellent and reminded us we love it there and will be back more often. The lobster Il Toscano over angle hair is amazing along with everything else. Most important is that Alex and everyone working there are very attentive, professional and show they value their customers.

Exceptional Dining at Prime 1024 – A Must-Visit! The host was friendly and welcoming We started with the robiola pizza, which was perfectly crisp with rich, creamy cheese—a fantastic way to kick off the meal. The sushi rolls were fresh, beautifully prepared, and packed with flavor, adding a delightful touch of variety. For the main courses, the porterhouse was cooked to perfection, juicy and flavorful, while the rack of lamb was tender with a beautifully seasoned crust(both served in hot black stone and table side cut). Lobster Pasta was Divine ,The side dishes were just as impressive—the Brussels sprouts had a perfect char, and the creamy truffle spinach was an indulgent, flavorful complement to the meal. To top it all off, dessert was a decadent treat, and the selection of red wine paired beautifully with our dishes, enhancing every bite. The ambiance is elegant yet inviting, making it perfect for a special night out. The service was attentive and knowledgeable, adding to an already fantastic experience. We were celebrating a birthday and Charlie by the way has a great singing voice If you’re looking for a restaurant that offers high-quality food, a great atmosphere, and top-notch service, Prime 1024 is a must-visit. I’ll definitely be returning!

I will always keep coming back not only for the food, but for Kenny!!!! He knows every change to the food and drink menus. He never disappoints. My last reservation was with a very good friend and she loved him!!! She loved every suggestion. We will be planning a larger event for a friend’s birthday and will ensure Kenny is around!!!

Always a fun time amazing food,drinks on point severs are amazing to detail. Bartenders rock!