Best Fine Dining Restaurants in Fisher Island

We were four people celebrating my birthday. My waiter was Maykel and he was fantastic. Everyone who works there has a great attitude, all willing to help the other, which is very unusual for a restaurant like this. It was a pleasant surprise and made my birthday super special. The food is meticulously done in such nice taste. Everything has a beautiful presentation. This is not the restaurant where you come starving because the portions are small but delicious. Every bite is an explosion of taste in your mouth. We ordered 12 different appetizers all amazing. The most impressive thing about this restaurant was the service and the energy inside. It’s just a great ambience. There was a fire dancer. The mood is fun. Thank you so much for making my birthday special.

Forte dei Marmi offers an exceptional dining experience with its elegant ambiance and authentic Italian cuisine. The food is perfectly prepared, with fresh ingredients that highlight traditional flavors. Francesco, our server, went above and beyond to make our evening unforgettable with his warm hospitality and impeccable attention to detail. His recommendations were spot-on, and he ensured every aspect of our meal was flawless. This restaurant is a must-visit for anyone looking for a true taste of Italy with outstanding service!

Birthday dinner after work. Ribeye and filet mignon were absolutely fantastic !!!

Will definitely return. Only negative was that even though the A/C was working, the restaurant was still very hot. Good and service was good.

It was our first time trying Indian food. I'm glad we ventured outside our comfort zone. We were pleasantly surprised with the great tasting dishes. We asked the waiter to go easy on us with the spices and he went outside the normal menu and got the chef to make us two special dishes (that was awesome service). The lamb dish was very good, they didn't have that gamey taste. The chicken dish was made with 3 different types of sauces (awesome too)! The rice was amazing (best rice I have ever had). Definitely will be coming back.