Best Date Night Restaurants in Water Mill

Wonderful ambience with friendly staff, decent service and great views.

Wonderful inventive food; great service; exceptional hosts!

I am not exaggerating when I say it was one of the best meals and dining experiences we've had anywhere. My wife and I, and a few friends visited after we had eloped at Jobson's Cove an hour prior. The staff was fantastic, drinks were amazing and the food was perfect. Most of us had steaks, cooked to perfection. Every bite truly delicious. After learning we were coming from our elopement, the staff all signed a card, announced us as newlywed to the other guests to make us feel special, surprised us with a dessert, and even found us at our resort afterwards to return a wedding memento we had left behind by accident. Can't say enough good things about our experience there. We count ourselves very lucky to have chosen to go to The Waterlot for our first dinner as a married couple.

Excellent service, excellent food. The drinks were on point. Very cozy atmosphere. It was the Perfect date night! Thank you so much for your kindness and your hospitality. Definitely coming back.

After many years of excellent meals, I had the best meal ever last night at BHI. The poached oysters and Dover sole were a religious experience. Kyle’s craft cocktails were stellar and it was marvelous to see Glenn and John before they are off on their well-deserved January vacation. AND….Elena was on top form; it’s always a delight to see her. Have a good break and see you in February.