Best Date Night Restaurants in Muskogee

The food was delicious, as usual. We got the Lasagne, Ravioli, and Chicken Parmesan. The Caesar salads are fresh with just the perfect amount of dressing. We took home the Chocolate mousse and the Tiramisu which were equally superb!

Came for a birthday but that was never acknowledged (and the staff didn’t ask)! Food was phenomenal however service was horrible. We were a 4 top there at 5:30 on a Wednesday night so the restaurant was far from busy! Waiter had a horrible attitude the entire dinner. The waiter didn’t bring the bread so we asked another staff member and they said they would ask him to bring it… 10 mins later still no bread so we flagged down our waiter and asked for bread and refills on our teas and soda. He acted put out by the request. When our dinner came it was missing items so we asked and again he acted like we were asking for to much! Our drinks stayed empty throughout most of the dinner because he never came to check on our table and we were scared to keep asking for refills! The waiter only had 2 other tables so I’d really hate to see how he treats guests when the restaurant is busy!!!

Our server was attentive, pleasant and efficient. The martini's were icy cold and delicious. The M steak salad was fantastic!

Love this place! It’s delicious! It is a little pricy but worth it. I didn’t know they charge $12 each, in addition to all you can eat price, for desserts, but that’s okay! They were yummy too! Highly recommended!

Edited review: Valentine’s Day experience was a little rough, BUT they redeemed theirselves with our next visit. In customer service, every experience won’t be perfect; but it’s what a business does when a mistake happens. Melting pot reached out and made it right. Our next experience was phenomenal. The service was awesome. Maddie, our waitress, was extremely attentive and personable. The service was efficient and the experience was calming and worth the visit. We will DEFINITELY be back. Thank you Rebekah and team!