Best Cosy Restaurants in Fisher Island

We got there for our 10:30 reservation but felt rushed when we arrived at 10:15pm. We were told we had 5 mins to order because the kitchen was closing. At 10:30pm only to see other tables be seated and received their orders after 11pm. Attentiveness of the staff was not that great as we only got asked if we wanted more drinks after we were done with dessert. Food quality was great though very tasty.

If you want to treat yourself on a special day, or any day, this is where you want to come. Every single item in the Experience was mouth watering, bursting of flavor. The Tree of Life was unlike anything I have tasted made out of Yuca root, and the truffle bunuelo literally melted in your mouth. The coffee field made you feel like you were floating on a cloud and it took me back home to Constanza, Dominican Republic. Just phenomenal. I was completely fascinated with the chocotherapy, never did I think I would lick my hands during am 18 course dinner. Our server, Pablo, was a burst of energy, full of knowledge and information about El Cielo. He has been with the company for over 10 years, and has seen the restaurants from the ground up. His passion for the restaurant and love of the industry is evident. Thank you Pablo!

Our Amara experience was a very good one. Our grilled fish and vegetables were delicious , good margarita! Lucas, our waiter was very helpful with our menu selections and the water views were beautiful!

Was my bd celebration. The setting is just stunning/magical. The waitress was outstanding. The food was delicious and presentation was gorgeous. DJ added to the ambiance and the little show was a great touch.

Salad was SO delicious. Outstanding service! Looking forward to returning soon!