7 Best Casual Restaurants in Shelter Island

7 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Claudio's Tavern & Grill restaurant

1. Claudio's Tavern & Grill

3.9

Excellent(335)

Price: Expensive

• Seafood • Greenport

Booked 5 times today

Step into the rich maritime history of Claudio’s Tavern & Grill, in the bustling port town of Greenport, New York. This 154 year old seaside legacy steeped in maritime charm, offers a warm welcome serving up delicious seasonal fare including local Day Boat Scallops and the best Ribeye in town. Join us to savor a taste of tradition and unwind in the heart of coastal charm.

A photo of The Terrace at the Pridwin restaurant

2. The Terrace at the Pridwin

4.5

Awesome(172)

Price: Very Expensive

• American • Shelter Island

Take your seat on The Terrace, the Pridwin's magnificent water-view restaurant and bar. Indoor seating spills out to the deck, where each seat commands spectacular views over Crescent Beach. True to Pridwin tradition, this reimagined restaurant serves classic Long Island food and drink—with a focus on high-quality ingredients sourced from local farms, fisherman, and makers.

3. Noah's

4.5

Awesome(2222)

Price: Expensive

• Tapas / Small Plates • Greenport

Booked 4 times today

noah's is known for its trademark seafood inspired small plates that places great emphasis on fresh, seasonal ingredients from the North Fork and East End of Long Island. Our menus change daily as they are created to reflect what’s in season from the local farmers, fishermen, artisans and wineries. *OUTDOOR DINING IS FIRST COME FIRST SERVE.*For parties of 5 or more. Please refer to our cancelation policy.*noah's has a private dining room for up to 50 seated guest. Please inquire about your next special event with us!

4. Olive Branch Cafe

4.4

Awesome(193)

Price: Expensive

• Mediterranean • Greenport

Booked 1 time today

Turkish Restaurant offering numerous Mediterranean menu items. Unwind in our comfortable atmosphere while sipping of a cup of coffer or tea. Join us for Breakfast, Lunch, or Dinner!

5. Sophie's Rest.

4.5

Awesome(48)

Price: Moderate

• American • Southold

Booked 2 times today

We refuse to compromise on quality in our restaurant. That's why we source our fresh ingredients from local farms and fish markets. Everything from in house hand cut steaks to our daily "catch of the day." No matter what time of year, you can be sure you're eating the best of the season.

6. Ram's Head Inn

4.5

Awesome(62)

Price: Very Expensive

• American • Shelter Island

The Ram's Head Inn is an inviting seaside getaway on Shelter Island with a relaxing atmosphere, gracious country accommodations, quality dining and warm hospitality. Executive chef Adam West coastal- American menu boasts fresh local produce, game and seafood, accompanied by harvests from the inn's garden. Guests can enjoy the beachfront without worry of heavy currents while enjoying a spectacular sunset.

7. M.J. Dowling's

4.4

Awesome(263)

Price: Moderate

• American • Sag Harbor

Booked 3 times today

Welcome to MJ Dowling’s Steakhouse and Tavern, a friendly neighborhood pub. Family owned and operated, MJ Dowling’s offers a casual dining experience with great food at reasonable prices. Featuring an eclectic menu, MJ’s is sure to please every member of your family. From juicy burgers and steaks to fajitas and nachos, we aim to please. Our nightly specials offer some of our most popular dishes at an even lower prices. Whether you are getting together with friends, going to happy hour or treating the family to a dinner out, MJ’s is the place to be! Be sure to check our game room which features two pool tables, a basketball hoop, and several arcade games!

Best Casual Restaurants in Shelter Island

Price

Cuisine

Regions

Areas

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Accessibility

7 restaurants available nearby

1. Claudio's Tavern & Grill

2. The Terrace at the Pridwin

3. Noah's

4. Olive Branch Cafe

5. Sophie's Rest.

6. Ram's Head Inn

7. M.J. Dowling's

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable