Best Casual Restaurants in Montclair

The food and service were both excellent. Donny room was mostly empty but the staff was very attentive. Food was fresh, hit and very good. We will be back!

Great food, great service consistently. Only negative is sometimes get sat at small corner booth that is not comfortable and has bad acoustics. Should be a discounted table if sat there.

Christmas morning, my mom, my daughter, and I decided to try brunch at Casa Maguey, and it was an absolutely wonderful experience! From the moment we walked in, the festive atmosphere and warm hospitality made us feel right at home. The highlight for us was their bottomless mimosas! Not only could you choose from classic orange, but they also offered sangria as an alternative, which was a unique and delicious twist. The drinks flowed freely and added a celebratory touch to our meal. The Mexican buffet was nothing short of amazing. The spread was full of authentic dishes that tasted homemade. From tamales to pozole, everything was flavorful and satisfying. They even had dessert options that left us tempted for seconds! The staff was attentive, keeping our glasses full and the buffet refreshed, even though it was a busy holiday morning. Overall, Casa Maguey provided a perfect blend of delicious food, great drinks, and warm ambiance. It was a memorable Christmas brunch for the three of us, and we’ll definitely be back for more. Highly recommend!

We’ve been going to this location for a long time and we always have a great experience. Food is always great! Today our waiter was Chuck and he was awesome! He checked up on us frequently, refilled our waters and brought us anything we asked for. He was super friendly and attentive!!!

Good service, yummy BBQ food. Was sitting outside, but still felt very warm under the heat lamp.