Best Casual Restaurants in Amityville

We had the opportunity to visit a new local restaurant tonight and I'm trying to find the proper adjectives. Let's start with refreshing. The decor was great and designed beautifully. Next.... Menu was great and packed with great choices and almost difficult to decide. So difficult that we ordered 4 entrees for 3 people. Why not. Food came quickly and everything looked great. Better than the look was the taste. Absolutely delicious. Freshest pasta I've had since having homemade at a Little Italy, NYC spot we frequent. This was just as good if not better. Seafood was fresh, my wife loves the chicken ala vodka and my son devoured the short rib. We had to try the desserts, cheesecake and fries Oreos for the win. Sure some people may get sticker shock from the prices - however it was worth every penny. I always say, I don't mind paying $1000.00 for a meal if it's delicious and memorable. Well add this to the memorable list! We are already planning our next reservation. Thank you MB - great food, great vibe, and great staff!

Kaycey was out a sweet & very accommodating waitress! Food was great ! Highly recommend !

This place is an absolute must— over and over again! I went with friends for a few apps… not realizing we should have brought a greater appetite! The service was outstanding- our waiter was attentive, knowledgeable and made great recommendations. The food was truly memorable, especially the fried artichokes, which were masterfully accompanied by an incredible lemon aioli, and the grilled octopus, which was tender and full of flavor. The bufalo burrata was fresh, creamy and just delicious— and the Romain style pizza was perfection. This will be a regular on the restaurant rotation, for its service and incredible menu— that I’ll be looking forward to trying one of everything!

We went at an off hour (2 PM) so got stuck between shifts. We lost our waiter halfway through the service. On the plus side we were able to speak with the chef. All of the food was fresh and inventive and locally sourced when possible (Shinnecock Bay scallops). This is a gastropub so expect elevated food in casual but cozy surroundings.

The food! The wine! The cozy "city" vibe. Salumi is always great. The best vegetable dishes I've ever had in my life and so many other unique and delicious choices. From boards to tapas to brunch to larger plates everything is always fantastic. The staff is extremely knowledgeable and the wine and drink choices are plentiful and top notch. I'd recommend Salumi to anyone who'd listen.