Best Authentic Restaurants in East Rockaway

The food was excellent. Our server Alejandro was very attentive even though it was a very busy Friday night. I would recommend the guacamole.

Exceeded expectations! Great food, great vibes, amazing service. 100% date night worthy with a nice dining room and bar area. Highly, highly recommended. Took my wife for Valentine's day dinner. We had a reservation and were immediately seated upon an on time arrival. The place was packed with couples, large groups and singles mingling by the bar. Our server greeted us with within minutes offering to take drink orders and to give us a bread basket. The service the entire night was spectacular! We were checked on by our server and a buser. We started with the martini and lavender lemonade. The martini was a 10/10 with blue cheese olives. The lemonade had a generous amount of purple top shelf gin. No complaints! The food is delicious. Started with the long hot peppers- blistered long Anaheim peppers with crispy crumbled sausage and (what I think was melted shaved parm) with bread crumbs on a bed of smashed spicy tomato and olive oil. It had a nice kick- 10/10 For entrees I had the boneless chicken scarp. What a dish! The sauce is not the typical type you'd get at a catering hall. It was much more flavorful with more depth. The potatoes, crispy sausage, boneless plancha'd chicken were perfect. I even ate my broccoli and carrot. Another 10/10. My wife had the sole. Slightly over done but she enjoyed. I have to say it looked great with the tomatoes and artichoke. We finished with the chocolate mousse with fresh strawberries and cream ... really, really good. The mouse had a slight coffee taste, it hits perfectly. Just a perfect way to end a great meal. The live music and lively crowd really made the vibes amazing. We'll be back and absolutely want to try more.

Our second visit here, and we hope to have many more. Delicious food, nice cocktails. The space is inviting and the music playlist was perfect. Service is wonderful; Benny is a treasure.

The atmosphere was outstanding. Live music, Great food and Drinks. Beautifully decorated. Love the place. Also very clean which I appreciate very much. There service was outstanding. I highly recommend for a night out with friends or a romantic evening for a date. I'm definitely going back.

This was not our first visit to Mythos. They were busy but it took a good 10-15 minutes for someone to come by to take our drink order. Additionally, the wait staff does not tell you about off menu offerings unless you specifically ask. The food has always been great but the service, although friendly and polite, needs some polish.