Best Steak Restaurants in Paoli

This was our first time eating Christmas dinner out. Our server, Justin, was the perfect balance of attentive and respectful. Loved that you could order from the full menu, as well as the special holiday offerings. Also appreciated that they were comfortably full, and tables were spaced appropriately so that guests weren't on top of each other. We were in the back dining room with a couple of larger tabletops as well as some 2 and 4-top tables. Food was perfectly prepared and served hot, and cocktails were delish. Very enjoyable. Highly recommended.

We knew Christmas Day dinner at Sullivan’s Steakhouse would be jamming as they were the only fine dining establishment around open all day. When we arrived at 1PM it was already 3/4s full. We were seated in the elevated section in the back where the private room is located although everything was open to accommodate all their guests. Malik was our head server and did an outstanding job in a stressed situation due to the large crowd with service assistance from Hunter and Brian. The old fashioned prepared by CJ was outstanding. We each had a shrimp cocktail (disappointing as these were NOT fine steakhouse quality - these were wet and long in the tooth), split a tasty Caesar salad. For our main course, we split a filet mignon on the bone, twin lobster tails, mashed potatoes (iced cold upon arrival & eventually removed from bill) and asparagus. Overall, a delightful meal. For a major holiday, they did a great job handling everything. We enjoyed the experience very much and will be back.

I enjoyed a Christmas Eve meal at the ever excellent Butcher + Singer. Everything was wonderful - from a warm welcome at check in, my fabulous, attentive server, Miss Brandy and, of course, the perfectly prepared food. Dining at Butcher + Singer is always a treat, but this particular meal will always be remembered as extra special. Thank you for another exceptional experience!

Riley our server was exceptional. Duck breast was tender and the polenta was the smoothest I ever had. Steak tartare with quail egg was the best I have ever had. We can’t wait to go back.

Everyone was amazing, party of 12 for a anniversary celebration , everyone including the guest of honor raved about our event 👏