Best Seafood Restaurants in Paia

The food and service at Honu Oceanside was truly exceptional—so much so that it’s worth saying again: exceptional! This restaurant is the real deal, clearly driven by strong leadership and an outstanding culinary team. Every detail, from the quality of ingredients to the presentation and incredible flavors, was perfectly executed. We sat at the bar due to limited reservations at sunset but that didn’t detract from a great view of sailboats at anchor and sunset behind Lana’i. Our server was amazing! To make our experience even more memorable, she thoughtfully acknowledged our anniversary with a complimentary champagne toast. It was a personal touch that spoke volumes about their commitment to guest experience. Highly recommend!

Amazing! Their charcoal cooked fish was amazing. Best fish we ever had. It’s pricey but it’s definitely enough food for 2-4 people and comes with 2 sides. My wife and I had enough leftover and added it to Caesar salads by the pool the next day. Definitely recommend getting the fish. The Maui onion dip was amazing too and could eat it all day long.

We celebrated our 1st anniversary @ Mala and returned for our 8th. The view is amazing, especially at sunset. Every dish we’ve had has been delicious but I think the seared scallops with Parmesan risotto is hard to beat! Carlos was a great server - just the right balance of attentiveness & space for us to enjoy our special date night. Mala was the only reservation I made prior to our trip to ensure we didn’t miss out. Highly recommended!

Napili Bay's culinary gem! This restaurant in West Maui is our go-to spot for both dinner and lunch, thanks to its charming ambiance and the island’s best sunset view. The nightly live Hawaiian music adds to the romantic evening outing for us. Here are some of the menu highlights and recommendations but you cannot go wrong with whatever you decide to eat there. They are all so delicious. Early Bird Dinner Specials: Available from 5:30 PM to 6:00 PM, featuring a salad, a main dish (choose from Mac Nut Hawaiian fish, Filet Mignon, or Sea House scampi), and a Tiramisu dessert, all for just $44. Reservations for 5:30 PM or 5:45 PM are essential as these spots fill up fast. Daily Dinner Specials: Including Lobster dinner on Tuesdays, my husband's favorite, and he thinks it is the best lobster dinner he has had. Although these specials don't come with salad or dessert, they are reasonably priced and packed with flavor. Other entrée options feature locally sourced fish and vegetarian dishes. Lunch Menu: Offers a variety of locally inspired dishes. My top pick is the Chicken Papaya Salad, but honestly, you can't go wrong with any choice. We have never tried their breakfast as we are not heavy breakfast eaters, but they have nice variety of breakfast staples with local flavors. Beyond the food, the friendly and knowledgeable servers elevate the dining experience. I highly recommend this restaurant to anyone visiting West Maui.

Storm was great‼️She was very attentive and gave wonderful Customer Service. The ladies at the front desk are always so accommodating. The food is yummy. My freind tried the new Lettuce wrap and loved it. Rick the Manager is outstanding in his overseeing the restaurant. Always a fantastic experience going to TB!