Best Pizzerias in Williamsburg

Visited Tarrant's to welcome new team member at work. Food was good but I wish they had a gluten free bread option so I could have had a sandwich. Love the Blueberry Lemonade.

Bottom's Up is so unique with their sourdough crust. I had the Chesapeake (crab meat) and my husband had the Rockefeller (smoked oysters) with thin crust. Both were excellent. We also had their side salad with balsamic dressing and it, too, was excellent. Matt was our server and he was very attentive. We will return!

Craft 31 Review I recently had the pleasure of dining at Craft 31, and it was a delightful experience! We ordered the wings and pizza, both of which were absolutely delicious. The wings were perfectly cooked, with a crispy exterior and juicy, flavorful meat. The pizza was equally impressive, with a well-balanced combination of toppings and a perfectly baked crust. One of the highlights of our visit was the atmosphere. We chose to sit in the heated and enclosed outdoor seating area, which provided a cozy and comfortable environment. It was the perfect spot to enjoy our meal, especially on a chilly evening. However, there was one area that could use improvement. The water glasses had a noticeable dishwasher film, and the water bottle was sticky and dirty. This detracted slightly from an otherwise excellent dining experience. Overall, Craft 31 offers a great dining experience with tasty food and a pleasant atmosphere. I highly recommend it to anyone looking for a nice place to eat and relax, but I hope they address the cleanliness of their glassware in the future.

Shorebreak on Shore Drive never ceases to impress me or those I’m lucky enough to share company with. Their menu is always fresh and delicious with specials that are well prepared and ultra tasty! Last night, it was grilled cheese with thick bacon strips, and a savory tomato bisque bowl, just dense enough for dipping yet not runny enough to escape the next bite. Outstanding on a cold night! My Wife had the blackened rockfish sandwich, and she said it was perfectly prepared but I wouldn’t know first hand because she devoured it before I could borrow a bite! Our waitress was preemptive as is typical with Shorebreak staff, very knowledgeable of the menu, courteous to all guests and extremely efficient on a busy Friday night. The kitchen is always super fast with turning over tickets but I have NEVER had food from Shorebreak that was precooked. Everything is always piping hot and out very quickly. The managers frequently visit the table to check on how everything is going and are super friendly. Ryan and Marissa were the Rock Stars last night but all of the managerial staff truly care about their customers and usually know the first names of most! Tony Jones, the magician, was in prime form last night and did about six magic tricks for us at our table-side. Tony works the house on Friday nights doing magic for all who are lucky enough to get his attention. He is a true professional to his tradecraft and it is evident with how precise his illusions can get. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED! He has a great YouTube channel if you want to see some of his stuff before you commit, but nothing compares to his table-side magic, you will be amazed! In closing, last night’s visit was spectacular but as you can tell, Shorebreak is a special kinda place. Thanks all who continue to keeping it my favorite in VB!!

Excellent food and server. Short wait to seated with reservation.