Best Pizzerias in Gates Mills

We are frequent visitors to 56 and have been there when it busy and when it’s less-than. I have never witnessed the place as hopping as it was in Valentine’s Day! Here’s the best part: why wife and I still had an intimate dinner, the food was amazingly consistent (excellent) with their usual standards, and service was impressively attentive and quick, just like always. I don’t know how they do it, but this establishment never disappoints! Which is why it’s on the top of our list of favorite neighborhood night out destinations. BRAVO!

The food was very good. House salad a little smaller than most. Lasagna and desserts were great. We were seated in an area that was a little crowded. It was fine until a second couple was seated to my right at a high table. I felt they crowded my personal space. Our server was not as efficient as we would have liked. Other than that I was a positive experience. We will go back for sure.

We love this place-food is great and the staff is awesome!! It’s a go to always!!!

Well, I wanted to take my cake home that I ordered with my surf dinner. The little girl brought me two pieces of cake. I said no I want them to go never came back with the cake I told my server I had to remind her that she came back with only the one piece of cake that was OK. Had to ask a few times where our drinks were. The lobster tails were a little tough on the bottom side, but otherwise they were pretty good. Broccoli was amazing. The lobster bisque was amazing. First time my grandson had it. All three pasta dinners were amazing. I took my daughter there when she was a baby and we moved away about the age of 11 and she wanted to go back because she remembered the buffet that we used to go to on Sundays. Truly wish you would bring that back.

BJ’s has added some menu items with some discount options that really do make a difference in saving a little. The food was delicious and very enjoyable. Like other restaurants in the area, it is still facing the challenge of needing more servers, but my wife and I still received great service. Well done! Recommended!