Best Italian Restaurants in Villas

13 restaurants available nearby

1. Mastello

4.8

Exceptional(455)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Fort Myers

Booked 24 times today

Mastello in Fort Myers is a gem for those seeking a premier steakhouse experience. Located conveniently near the Barbara B. Mann Theatre, this elegantly revamped venue is celebrated for its prime cuts and American Wagyu, ensuring a top-tier dining indulgence. Patrons rave about the "most delicious and well-seasoned filets" and the "perfectly prepared Wagyu top cut sirloin," highlighting the exceptional quality of the meats. With over 100 wine selections and a sophisticated cocktail bar, Mastello not only promises a delightful meal but a luxurious atmosphere perfect for any special occasion. As one diner put it, this is the place for "an upscale evening out," making every visit to Mastello a memorable feast of flavors and impeccable service.

A photo of La Fontanella Ristorante - Fort Myers restaurant

2. La Fontanella Ristorante - Fort Myers

4.7

Exceptional(207)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • McGregor

Booked 5 times today

We're glad that you're here. We pride ourselves in serving you authentic, from-scratch Italian dishes made only from the freshest, highest quality ingredients. We provide a vast selection of fine wines and hand crafted cocktails to further culminate your meal, and fresh, from-scratch desserts to conclude. Along with our warm, inviting atmosphere and friendly professional service, you can be assured that we at La Fontanella strive to exceed your expectations each time that you join us for a meal. It is always our pleasure to serve you. We look forward to meeting you.

3. il Pomodoro

4.8

Exceptional(353)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Fort Myers

Booked 4 times today

Il Pomodoro in Fort Myers offers an authentic Sicilian dining experience that's been consistently lauded as one of the best in Southwest Florida. With a string of prestigious accolades including the Trip Advisor’s Traveler’s Choice Award and multiple News Press Restaurants of the Year rankings, diners are guaranteed a meal that transcends the ordinary. Guests rave about the "outstanding" Shrimp Fra Diavolo and the "amazing" rigatoni bolognese, emphasizing both the quality and the generous portion sizes. One reviewer exclaimed, "This is the best Italian I have EVER eaten!!" which is a testament to the restaurant's commitment to authenticity and excellence. Whether you're there for a cozy date night or a festive family gathering, Il Pomodoro promises an unforgettable culinary journey through the heart of Sicily.

A photo of Terra Nostra Restaurant restaurant

4. Terra Nostra Restaurant

4.9

Exceptional(2049)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Fort Myers Beach

Booked 38 times today

Terra Nostra Restaurant near Fort Myers Beach delivers an exceptional seafood dining experience that consistently impresses both locals and visitors. Renowned for its "delicious" seafood offerings, guests rave about dishes like the succulent grouper, praised for its freshness and superb seasoning. The restaurant's location just minutes from Sanibel adds a charming allure, perfect for enjoying seafood fresh from the nearby waters. Patrons often highlight the excellent service, with comments such as "the food and service were amazing!" and "service was excellent." Terra Nostra's commitment to quality and an enchanting dining environment makes it a standout destination for seafood lovers seeking authenticity and excellence in Fort Myers.

A photo of San Matteo Italian Restaurant & Bar restaurant

5. San Matteo Italian Restaurant & Bar

4.5

Awesome(295)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • San Carlos Park

Booked 4 times today

San Matteo Italian Restaurant & Bar in San Carlos Park, Fort Myers, truly stands out as a premier destination for authentic Neapolitan-style pizza. Praised for its "phenomenal" quality and authenticity, the restaurant offers a slice of Italy with its award-winning pizzas that are a delight to both locals and visitors. Guests rave about the Margherita and Napoli pizzas, noting they are "just like the pizza we had in Naples." The secret lies in the ingredients, with flour imported directly from Italy, ensuring each bite is as authentic as it is delicious. Coupled with a vibrant atmosphere and exceptional service, San Matteo is the go-to place for anyone craving genuine Italian pizza. This pizzeria is not just a meal; it's an experience that brings a piece of Italy right to your table.

6. 41 Bistro

4.8

Exceptional(250)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • San Carlos Park

Booked 30 times today

41 Bistro in San Carlos Park, Fort Myers, is a culinary haven for steak lovers. This exceptional dining spot combines Italian flair with the art of steak preparation, ensuring each dish is a masterpiece. Patrons rave about the quality, with one guest proclaiming the steak as "very good," highlighting its prominence alongside other Italian specialties. The restaurant's dedication to fine ingredients and skillful cooking shines through, making every steak dish a delectable journey of flavors. Whether it's a romantic dinner or a special gathering, 41 Bistro promises an unforgettable steak experience that keeps guests coming back for more. Celebrate your next steak dinner at 41 Bistro, where tradition meets excellence.

A photo of Rae's Real Italian restaurant

7. Rae's Real Italian

4.6

Exceptional(276)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Fort Myers

Booked 9 times today

Rae's Real Italian in Fort Myers Beach offers an authentic American dining experience that captures the essence of gourmet Italian cuisine with a unique American twist. Nestled within the scenic Pink Shell Beach Resort and Marina, Rae's provides a delightful fusion of traditional and contemporary flavors that cater to all ages. Guests rave about the "best meal we had all weekend" and praise the "unique and delicious" Key Lime Cannolis, highlighting the restaurant's commitment to quality and creativity. With its stunning Gulf of Mexico views and exceptional service, Rae's Real Italian is not just a meal; it's a culinary journey that resonates deeply with the American palate, making it a must-visit destination on Fort Myers Beach.

8. Trattoria Ciao

4.9

Exceptional(122)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Cape Coral

Booked 5 times today

Trattoria Ciao in Cape Coral is a haven for those seeking genuine Italian cuisine, where the aromas and flavors transport you straight to Italy. Praised for its "authentic Italian garlic bread" and described as a place where "everything was so so delicious," it's clear that Trattoria Ciao masters the art of Italian cooking. A patron raved about the "wild mushroom arancini" as "better than the ones I had in Italy," showcasing the restaurant's commitment to authentic and exquisitely prepared dishes. The cozy ambiance, complemented by live music, ensures a dining experience that's both "intimate" and "romantic," making every visit memorable. Whether it's the wood-fired pizzas or the "best shrimp piccata" ever tasted, Trattoria Ciao consistently exceeds expectations, making it a must-visit for anyone craving a taste of Italy in Florida.

9. Next Door

4.9

Exceptional(160)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Cape Coral

Booked 4 times today

Next Door in Cape Coral offers an exceptional dining experience that highlights the best of Contemporary American cuisine with a delightful modern twist. Patrons consistently rave about the unique and delicious flavor combinations, such as the "basil infused pasta" and the "wagyu carpaccio," underscoring the chef's skill in elevating traditional dishes. One reviewer exclaimed, "The chef nailed it with the unexpected & complimentary tasting of the asparagus puree with microgreens," emphasizing the creativity and quality that Next Door brings to every dish. Frequent guests appreciate not only the food but also the atmosphere, describing it as their "favorite date nightspot." With its commitment to freshness, evident in their daily handmade pastas, and a market for those who wish to bring a taste of Next Door home, this restaurant truly stands out in the Cape Coral culinary scene.

A photo of Caffe' da Michele LLC restaurant

10. Caffe' da Michele LLC

3.4

Very Good(113)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • San Carlos Park

Booked 2 times today

"Caffe' da Michele Osteria Italiana is bringing traditional Favorites homemade Italian fare, such as Fettuccine Bolognese, Rigatoni all' Amatriciana and Lasagna di Carne"

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you

T
ThomasVIP
Las Vegas •9 reviews
5.0
Dined 3 days ago
First time visiting this hidden gem. We both had veal dishes that were excellent. High quality ingredients prepared right. Server Rick was very knowledgeable about the menu and steered us right. Nice bar for a pre dinner cocktail. We will return
More info
La Fontanella Ristorante - Fort MyersPrice: Moderate• Italian• McGregor
•
4.7
T
Thor
New Jersey •1 review
5.0
Dined 3 days ago
A must go! Attentive staff upon entering, piano player was engaging, the room was filled with diners who were dressed for a night out, our server,Jared, was informative on menu, wine and the restaurant seating options. He gave great recommendations. Extensive wine list. The amuse bouche to start was a nice touch - beets and marscapone on a spoon. The bread and garlic butter was so so worth it to have two! Eggplant rolatini,Halibut, Pork osso bucco and chocolate cake were all spectacular. Rebooked for next week.
More info
Angelina's RistorantePrice: Expensive• Italian• Bonita Springs
•
4.8
K
Karen
Orange County •1 review
5.0
Dined 5 days ago
Our experience tonight was wonderful. One of the things I don't like about a restaurant is that it is too high of a noise level. I do not like having trouble hearing people at our own table. You don't have to worry about that at Terra Nostra. The tables are not on top of one another, like at other restaurants (Coopers Hawk). We will be coming back, and the food is phenomenal. It was the best linguine with clam sauce I have ever had in my life. Thank you, Terra Nostra.
More info
Terra Nostra RestaurantPrice: Expensive• Italian• Fort Myers Beach
•
4.9
W
Wayne
Las Vegas •7 reviews
5.0
Dined 5 days ago
We really enjoyed Mastello’s - service was fantastic and the menu offered a great selection of entrees. The Sea Bass was excellent. Would highly recommend. Enjoy!!
More info
MastelloPrice: Expensive• Steakhouse• Fort Myers
•
4.8
J
JoeVIP
Columbus •132 reviews
5.0
Dined 7 days ago
What a great night at Il Pomodoro! It felt like a 1960’s dinner club in New York City! Awesome food and the wonderful atmosphere driven by the music from the incredible Dave Powers!! To top it off, Dave played the song that a couple in the audience danced to at their wedding 66 years ago! Awesome again!!
More info
il PomodoroPrice: Moderate• Italian• Fort Myers
•
4.8

Explore OpenTable

Villas

Italian

Best Italian Restaurants in Villas

Price

Regions

Areas

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Accessibility

13 restaurants available nearby

1. Mastello

2. La Fontanella Ristorante - Fort Myers

3. il Pomodoro

4. Terra Nostra Restaurant

5. San Matteo Italian Restaurant & Bar

6. 41 Bistro

7. Rae's Real Italian

8. Trattoria Ciao

9. Next Door

10. Caffe' da Michele LLC

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable