Best Italian Restaurants in Sanibel

I am always blown away by the great food that we experience at Angelina’s. What a gem in the SW Florida area. The halibut was outstanding and the meatballs as an app was exceptional. Our server was super knowledgeable on the wine selection and provided us with individual recommendations based on our description of what we were looking for.

Friends wanted to return for the "Early seating " before 5 pm for the value dinners and drinks. This was our first time and we were reluctant to dine so early. We left happy, well fed with enough for a second dinner tonight. The house wine was very good and at 6 the entertainment was just beginning. It was a delightful atmosphere, great service and equally great food and drinks . I would return again to experience the menu as a whole, not just the early offerings before 5 pm. The only problem with dining later appeared to be very tight parking. Not too much of a deterrent.

Beautiful space and outstanding food. Our server was great! I would have loved to purchase some deli meats at the market but there was only one person working the deli. There were two people working the meat counter that did not have customers. But apparently they cannot assist in the deli, which had a long line. I did purchase some bakery items, which were delicious!

Food is always very consistent

Delicious as usual. Always good to be back at the pink shell and know that we don’t have to go anywhere for a great dinner!