Best Italian Restaurants in Michigan City, IN
Price
- $40 and under
- $41 to $70
- $71 and over
Regions
Areas
Top Rated
Dining Options
Seating Options
Accessibility
4 restaurants available nearby
How is content generated
See what locals rave about
- TTylerChicago / Illinois •2 reviews5.0Dined 1 day agoService was outstanding! Sat right by the fire and the overall ambiance was perfect for a date night! Best drinks and pasta we’ve had! The chefs were on point from the appetizers to the desserts! Definitely going back soon!More infoBrewster’s New BuffaloPrice: Moderate• Italian• New Buffalo•4.8
- JJanelleChicago / Illinois •1 review5.0Dined 3 days agoMy husband and I made a reservation at Sonny D’s for Valentine’s Day. The atmosphere was beautiful. The restaurant was super clean and modern and our waitress was a gem. 10 out of 10 would highly recommend. I will definitely come back when I am in the new Buffalo area again.More infoSonny D's Bar & GrillPrice: Moderate• American• New Buffalo•4.8
- KKathyCincinnati / Dayton •1 review5.0Dined 3 days agoFood was amazing! The bread and marina they brought to table was so good. Even though it was Valentines Day we were not rushed. Would definitely drive the 2 1/2 hours to eat there againMore infoFarina's Supper ClubPrice: Expensive• Steak• Michigan City, IN•4.8
- SSunshineVIPChicago / Illinois •13 reviews5.0Dined 4 days agoBeautiful atmosphere and decor with incredible views. House music played in the background, the bar is gorgeous and the people are here to see and be seen. Thankfully, the food and service stands up to the see and be seen portion of this experience. Service was amazing, our server was warm, friendly, happy to make suggestions, and funny. We really enjoyed her. The food was delicious - panzanella salad "like summer in a bowl" followed by the wild boar ragu (divinely rich and silky) and then a filete di manzo with parmesan roasted fennel and smashed potatoes. The steak is smoky, with a nice crust on the outside but rare, sweet and tender on the inside. At first, we had FOMO over the pasta, thinking we should have ordered two pastas. Once we had tiramisu for dessert (which was impossibly creamy and rich), we were glad we didn't order a 2nd pasta because we were so full. We ate very well and laughed about it as we rolled out of the St Regis to the car. We had the Blanco Bianco Amargo, a tequila/mezcal drink, and it was divinely crafted with a lovely finish. Everything here is well thought out and carefully executed. I asked our server to surprise me with a glass of red wine suitable for the pasta and steak. She gave me a Barbera, which worked well with the intense richness of the boar and beef. This is a romantic atmosphere, with lots of space and service is such that it allows privacy and the staff understand that. Highly recommend the experience for a date night!More infoTre DitaPrice: Very Expensive• Italian• River North (Chicago)•4.8
- KKellyVIPLondon •3 reviews5.0Dined on 7 Feb 2025We had meatballs as a starter, then the bacon pasta entree on special and the linguini and clams in white sauce as entrees. Every bite was delicious!More infoCafe FarinaPrice: Expensive• Italian• Michigan City, IN•4.7
Discover best Italian restaurants in Michigan City, IN
Discover the essence of Italian cuisine in Michigan City, IN, Chicago / Illinois, and Northwest Indiana with our curated selection of Italian restaurants. Each establishment offers a unique blend of authentic flavors and modern culinary techniques, ensuring a delightful dining experience for every palate. The region is known for its vibrant dining scene, where traditional Italian dishes meet local culinary traditions, creating a fusion that's both innovative and rooted in history. Patrons can expect a variety of options, from classic pasta and pizza to innovative seafood and meat dishes, all prepared with fresh, high-quality ingredients. These restaurants are celebrated for their warm, inviting atmospheres and exceptional service, making them perfect spots for both casual dinners and special occasions. Whether you're a local foodie or a visitor looking to taste the best of Italian cuisine, these establishments promise an unforgettable culinary journey right in the heart of the Midwest.