Best Italian Restaurants in Cutler Bay

13 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Anacapri - Pinecrest restaurant

1. Anacapri - Pinecrest

4.9

Exceptional(1137)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Pinecrest

Booked 38 times today

Anacapri’s Italian cuisine is full of the kind of simple, unforgettable dishes that keep regulars coming back. The casual but fine-dining atmosphere will provide you with the perfect venue whether you’re out for a romantic evening or celebrating with your friends. It is elegant yet familiar and once you’re here, you’re family. As the past, present, and future generation in Italian food, Anacapri’s cuisine will never go out of style.

2. Caffe Portofino

4.9

Exceptional(773)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Palmetto Bay

Caffe Portofino in Palmetto Bay, Miami, is a gem of Contemporary Italian cuisine, celebrated for its eclectic fusion of Italian zest with Caribbean flavors. Since its inception in 2005, this restaurant has crafted a dining experience that resonates with both authenticity and innovation. Patrons consistently laud the "excellent food" and the warmly "outstanding service," making it a beloved neighborhood staple. Reviews often highlight the "daily specials" and the "fresh ingredients" that elevate each dish, ensuring a meal that is "always on point." The ambiance is described as "relaxing and elegant," perfect for enjoying meals that are "simply terrific." As one diner raves, the seafood risotto and the pasta dishes are not to be missed, promising that you'll "be back in a heartbeat" for more of Caffe Portofino's delightful offerings.

3. Pilón Miami

3.9

Excellent(28)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Three Lakes

Booked 2 times today

At Pilón Miami, nestled in the scenic Three Lakes neighborhood of Miami, the essence of Latin American cuisine is celebrated with an unwavering commitment to authenticity and excellence. Chef Yudiming Puche masterfully crafts dishes that are a symphony of flavors, with standouts like the Salmón Ahumado and "Los Datiles" drawing diners back time and again. Patrons rave about the "amazing" food and the handcrafted cocktails, such as "Ay Bendito" and "Mora Pa' Rumba," which perfectly encapsulate the vibrant spirit of Latin America. With its charming lake-view patios and lively atmosphere, Pilón Miami offers a dining experience that is both enchanting and deeply rooted in Latin American culinary traditions. As one satisfied diner put it, this place is a "true hidden gem" with food that makes you "narrow your eyes and swallow slowly, deeply enjoying all its flavor."

4. Fiola Miami

4.8

Exceptional(3187)

Price: Very Expensive

• Italian • Coral Gables

Booked 27 times today

Fiola Miami, nestled in the picturesque Coral Gables, is a beacon of Italian culinary excellence, celebrated for its Michelin-starred pedigree and innovative interpretation of Italian classics. A favorite among locals and visitors alike, Fiola Miami’s commitment to authenticity is evident in every dish. As one diner raves, the experience is "simply exquisite with not a single bad bite." The restaurant's impressive wine selection complements a menu that blends traditional Italian flavors with local ingredients, creating "a delightful lunch with excellent food and excellent service" that keeps patrons returning. Whether it’s for a Prix Fixe Lunch, a Sunday Brunch, or a special dinner, Fiola Miami delivers an Italian dining experience that is both luxurious and deeply satisfying.

A photo of North Italia - Dadeland restaurant

5. North Italia - Dadeland

4.5

Awesome(745)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Kendall

Booked 21 times today

North Italia in Dadeland is a haven for authentic Italian cuisine, where every dish is crafted from scratch with a focus on fresh, seasonal ingredients. Renowned for its inventive flavors and mastery in handmade pastas and pizzas, the restaurant promises a "modern Italia experience" that delights with every bite. Customers rave about their experiences, with one noting, "the food is always consistently great" and another praising the "amazing food and great service." The crafted seasonal cocktails are also highlighted as perfect complements to the meals. Whether it's a family dinner or a special brunch, North Italia stands out as a top choice for Italian dining in Kendall, Miami, offering both excellent food and a welcoming atmosphere.

A photo of Fratelli By Jholano's restaurant

6. Fratelli By Jholano's

4.5

Awesome(31)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • South Miami

Booked 3 times today

We are a local family owned restaurant, with an Italian concept inspired by the historical food culture originating from the streets of Rome. Our expertise is in the simplicity of Rome, where at any given moment in the city streets you can find something to satisfy your taste buds. From hot, spicy, to sweet, or refreshing just like in Rome, here at Fratelli’s there is a dish for everyone to enjoy.

A photo of Graziano's Bird Road restaurant

7. Graziano's Bird Road

4.7

Exceptional(585)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Westchester

Booked 24 times today

Graziano's Bird Road in Westchester, Miami, is a culinary gem that delights diners with its impeccable Italian cuisine. Despite its Argentine roots, the restaurant excels in delivering sumptuous Italian dishes, cooked with authenticity and a passion for rich flavors. Patrons often rave about the quality and atmosphere, with one customer noting, "The food was delicious, the decor and ambiance of the restaurant was superb, and the employees were very welcoming." Another diner recommended, "If you are ordering meat definitely add the peppercorns sauce!" ensuring a personalized touch to their robust Italian offerings. Graziano’s is celebrated for its attentive service and a cozy, inviting atmosphere, making it a must-visit for a guaranteed delightful Italian dining experience in Miami.

A photo of NOMA BEACH at Redfish restaurant

8. NOMA BEACH at Redfish

4.5

Awesome(514)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • South Miami

Booked 22 times today

NOMA Beach at Redfish in Coral Gables epitomizes Italian culinary excellence with its unique waterfront charm and delectable coastal Italian cuisine crafted by Chef Donatella. The restaurant's commitment to authenticity is evident in dishes like the perfectly al dente carbonara, which a diner described as "true authentic tasting Italian carbonara pasta here in Miami." Each meal is a testament to Donatella’s Italian roots and culinary prowess, with guests consistently praising not only the food but the atmosphere and service, calling it "a must-visit destination for food enthusiasts." With its stunning ocean views and delightful ambiance, NOMA Beach at Redfish is the quintessential spot for an exceptional Italian dining experience in Miami.

A photo of Coppola's Bistro Ristorante Kendall restaurant

9. Coppola's Bistro Ristorante Kendall

4.6

Exceptional(172)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Sunset

Booked 6 times today

If you are looking for the best Italian food in South Florida, look no further than Coppola's Bistro Ristorante. This local Italian restaurant always serves freshly cooked food to order. The friendly and attentive staff are the only thing more pleasant than the food. Our signature dish, Ossobuco di Manzo al Risotto, will leave you coming back for more. Finish off your meal with the best Tiramisù Fatto in Casa in town. Come and enjoy this Italian atmosphere inside our restaurant. With recipes that have been passed down through generations, and an experience you would never forget, nothing beats Coppola's Bistro Ristorante!

A photo of Pulcinella Brick Oven Pizzeria restaurant

10. Pulcinella Brick Oven Pizzeria

(0)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • The Crossings

Pulcinella Brick Oven Pizzeria in The Crossings, Miami, truly captures the essence of Italian cuisine with its authentic New York and Neapolitan-style pizzas, homemade pasta, and sumptuous subs. Guests consistently rave about the "exquisite" Spaghetti Carbonara and the freshness of ingredients in dishes like the calzone. One reviewer exclaimed, "The food was delicious and the service was wonderful. Will definitely be going back!" The cozy atmosphere complements the quality of the food, making it a "hidden gem" in Miami for Italian delights. Whether it's the crispy, hot pizzas or the meticulously seasoned pasta, Pulcinella promises an Italian dining experience that's both memorable and delightful.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you

F
Fay
Toronto / Ontario •1 review
5.0
Dined 2 days ago
The mansion does not fail! It was beautiful like always! Great food and the staff (servers) were very very sweet. Especially our one server. The girls at the front can look a bit unfriendly, to the point that makes you a bit unwelcome but overall it was a beautiful Christmas Day at the Versace mansion. Maybe a little renovation on the chairs would be good too. It is price friendly (kinda) so in my opinion, the furniture should reflect the “luxury” look. At least a good cleanup. The food was really good, we had the spaghetti with lobster.. the burrata was amazing.. drinks pretty good.. no complaints at all! Thank you for making our Christmas 2025 beautiful all the way from Canada!
More info
Gianni's at the Former Versace MansionPrice: Expensive• Italian• South Beach
•
4.5
V
Victoria
Miami - Dade •1 review
5.0
Dined on 19 Dec 2024
So far one of the best restaurant in Miami. Amazing service, Food was delicious, beyond expectations and the place is beautiful. Coming back soon!!
More info
Fiola MiamiPrice: Very Expensive• Italian• Coral Gables
•
4.8
D
DonaldVIP
Southwest Florida •66 reviews
5.0
Dined on 17 Dec 2024
Absolutely fabulous! Had our Christmas luncheon here and the service and food was outstanding! Everyone left full, satisfied and raving about how good everything was. Thank you again!!
More info
Anacapri - PinecrestPrice: Expensive• Italian• Pinecrest
•
4.9
M
Mark
Greater Boston •14 reviews
5.0
Dined on 12 Dec 2024
Outstanding experience, the food the wine choices the service and the customization of entrees to meet the needs of my guests. Just an overall outstanding experience congratulations 👏👏
More info
Caffe PortofinoPrice: Moderate• Italian• Palmetto Bay
•
4.9
E
Elvin
Miami - Dade •1 review
5.0
Dined on 29 Nov 2024
Perfect place nice decoration menu and price good definitely I will go again
More info
Pilón MiamiPrice: Moderate• Latin American• Three Lakes
•
3.9

Explore OpenTable

Cutler Bay

Italian

Best Italian Restaurants in Cutler Bay

Price

Regions

Areas

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Award-winning

Accessibility

13 restaurants available nearby

1. Anacapri - Pinecrest

2. Caffe Portofino

3. Pilón Miami

4. Fiola Miami

5. North Italia - Dadeland

6. Fratelli By Jholano's

7. Graziano's Bird Road

8. NOMA BEACH at Redfish

9. Coppola's Bistro Ristorante Kendall

10. Pulcinella Brick Oven Pizzeria

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable