Best Italian Restaurants in Bentleyville

26 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Mezzo at Sienna Mercato - Second Floor Only restaurant

1. Mezzo at Sienna Mercato - Second Floor Only

4.3

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Downtown

Booked 10 times today

Mezzo at Sienna Mercato, nestled in the vibrant Cultural District of Downtown Pittsburgh, is a celebrated haven for contemporary Italian cuisine. Despite current menu modifications due to kitchen repairs, patrons continue to rave about the "amazing" food and drinks, particularly praising the "phenomenal culinary experience" crafted by Chef Jared. With a menu that boasts dishes like Seafood Agliolio and a praised short rib Ragu, Mezzo maintains its reputation through an unwavering commitment to quality and authenticity. Guests are encouraged by the knowledgeable staff, like Emma and Daisy, who enhance the dining experience with their attentiveness. Reviews consistently highlight Mezzo as a must-visit, with comments like the food being "amazingly prepared" and experiences that are "10/10." Whether it's for a memorable birthday dinner or a casual brunch before a theater matinee, Mezzo promises a stellar contemporary Italian meal in the heart of Pittsburgh.

2. Alla Famiglia

4.9

Exceptional(945)

Price: Very Expensive

• Italian • South Side

Booked 38 times today

At Alla Famiglia in Pittsburgh’s South Side, the seafood cuisine is a standout, capturing the essence of authentic Italian culinary traditions. Celebrated for its "best ever seafood fra diavolo," diners consistently praise the freshness and flavor of the seafood offerings. One guest exclaims, "We had the seafood fra diavolo. Best we have ever had." The restaurant's meticulous selection of daily provisioned fishes and exotic sea delights ensures each dish resonates with the vibrant, true tastes of Italy. With glowing reviews highlighting the knowledgeable staff and the exceptional culinary experience, Alla Famiglia promises not just a meal but a voyage into the heart of Italian seafood artistry.

A photo of Pizzaiolo Primo - Market Square restaurant

3. Pizzaiolo Primo - Market Square

4.7

Exceptional(940)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Downtown

Booked 51 times today

Welcome to Pizzaiolo Primo, a gem in Pittsburgh's Market Square renowned for its exceptional Italian pizzeria cuisine. At the heart of Pizzaiolo Primo is the commitment to old-world Neapolitan pizza-making techniques combined with the finest ingredients, ensuring every slice is a taste of Italy. Guests consistently rave about the quality, with reviews highlighting the "best woodfire pizza downtown" and describing it as "authentic Italian cuisine, delicious." Whether it's the perfect crust of their pizzas or the innovative dishes like the "Special pickle pizza," Pizzaiolo Primo delivers an outstanding dining experience. As one reviewer puts it, this place offers "a little bit of Italy in downtown Pittsburgh," making every visit memorable.

A photo of Alta Via - Market Square restaurant

4. Alta Via - Market Square

4.5

Awesome(481)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Downtown

Booked 40 times today

Nestled in the heart of Pittsburgh's bustling Downtown Market Square, Alta Via stands out as a beacon of Modern Tuscan cuisine. With an emphasis on wood hearth cooking and fresh handmade pastas, this restaurant is a celebration of both tradition and modernity, using passionately sourced ingredients to craft dishes that are both fresh and authentic. Reviewers rave about their experiences, with one noting, "The food was amazing, wish we had gotten the bigger portions to take home with us!" and another exclaiming about the "largest, most tender scallops" they've ever eaten, served in an "incredible" rhubarb sauce. Every dish at Alta Via promises a journey through the delightful flavors of modern Italy, right in the heart of Pittsburgh.

A photo of Talia Cucina Rosticceria restaurant

5. Talia Cucina Rosticceria

4.7

Exceptional(825)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Downtown

Booked 18 times today

Talia Cucina Rosticceria, nestled in the heart of downtown Pittsburgh, offers a delightful exploration of Contemporary Italian cuisine with a rustic twist. Celebrated for its use of locally sourced ingredients and housing Pittsburgh’s only Amari Bar, Talia stands out for its originality and quality. Diners rave about their experiences, noting the "fantastic" food and "warm and welcoming" staff. Highlights include the "delicious" focaccia paired with pistachio honey butter and the creatively presented ricotta gnocchi with lobster. With its cozy yet elegant atmosphere, Talia not only promises but delivers an authentic Italian dining experience that keeps guests returning for more.

A photo of Vallozzi's Pittsburgh restaurant

6. Vallozzi's Pittsburgh

4.5

Awesome(2248)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Downtown

Booked 16 times today

Vallozzi's Pittsburgh has become a beacon of comfort food excellence in the heart of Downtown Pittsburgh. Celebrated for its deep-rooted Italian traditions and exceptional cuisine, this family-operated gem offers a delightful array of homemade pastas and classic Italian dishes that embody authentic comfort food. With accolades such as the Wine Spectator Magazine's Best of Award of Excellence, Vallozzi’s commitment to quality is unmistakable. Patrons rave about the "delicious and ample portions" and the "home-made pasta" that make each visit memorable. Reviews consistently praise the restaurant for its "outstanding food and service," highlighting dishes like the Chicken Saltimbocca and the uniquely splendid lasagne. Vallozzi's Pittsburgh is undoubtedly a must-visit for anyone seeking a comforting, gourmet experience in a warm and welcoming atmosphere.

7. Emerson’s

4.6

Exceptional(344)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Downtown

Booked 14 times today

Nestled in the vibrant heart of Downtown Pittsburgh, Emerson’s stands out as a beacon of Italian culinary excellence. Praised for its authentic Italian dishes, this charming restaurant offers a menu that dazzles with traditional flavors and innovative twists. Diners rave about the "perfectly cooked" penne alla vodka and the "delicious" burrata, emphasizing the quality and authenticity that Emerson's brings to every dish. The atmosphere is described as "unlike any other place in Pittsburgh," making it a must-visit for anyone craving an exceptional Italian meal. With glowing reviews like "one of the best places to dine if you are in Pittsburgh" and cocktails described as "FANTASTIC," Emerson’s is clearly a beloved gem in the city’s culinary scene.

8. Fish nor Fowl

4.7

Exceptional(523)

Price: Very Expensive

• Italian • East Liberty

Booked 11 times today

At Fish nor Fowl in Pittsburgh's East Liberty neighborhood, the fusion of Italian-inspired dishes with modern, eclectic twists offers a truly unique dining experience. Chef Richard DeShantz's approach to the menu focuses on high-quality ingredients and simple yet elegant executions, creating unforgettable meals that keep diners coming back. Patrons rave about the "gorgeously plated" dishes and "outstanding" service, noting that the seafood linguine and bone marrow risotto are must-try items. The restaurant's chic, naturally designed space adds to the charm, making every visit "a pleasurable experience." Whether it's the whipped ricotta or the creatively served zucchini flowers, Fish nor Fowl masters the art of fusion cuisine, making it a celebrated culinary destination in Pittsburgh.

A photo of Martorano's Prime Pittsburgh restaurant

9. Martorano's Prime Pittsburgh

4.5

Awesome(1085)

Price: Very Expensive

• Italian • Downtown

Booked 11 times today

Martorano's Prime in Downtown Pittsburgh is renowned for its stellar Steak cuisine, particularly the 16oz Prime New York Strip Martorano, which is a true testament to the restaurant's commitment to quality and authenticity. The steak, enhanced with hot & sweet peppers and sharp provolone cheese, has earned rave reviews, with one guest exclaiming it was the "best strip steak he ever had!" This signature dish embodies the restaurant's fusion of Italian-American flavors, ensuring a memorable dining experience. The upscale, vibrant atmosphere, combined with attentive service, makes Martorano's Prime a must-visit for steak lovers seeking an exceptional meal in a lively setting.

10. Alfabeto

4.5

Awesome(728)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Northside

Booked 3 times today

Authentic Northern Italian restaurant, by international Executive Chef Maurizio Esposito.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you

J
joy
Pittsburgh / Western PA •2 reviews
5.0
Dined 3 days ago
We hosted a large group of teenagers for our daughter’s birthday and it was the perfect dinner spot. The staff really made the night - outstanding service.
More info
Pizzaiolo Primo - Market SquarePrice: Expensive• Italian• Downtown
•
4.7
K
Kristenvip
Pittsburgh / Western PA •24 reviews
5.0
Dined 3 days ago
Talia is our favorite spot - hands down! They rotate seasonal menus to keep things fresh, while preserving the fan favorites (like cauliflower dip!!!). The wine list is excellent, featuring a fantastic Italian variety, unique to the city. Though the food always hits - it's the service that we value the most! Melissa and her team make every guest feel like family. Can't wait until our next visit!!
More info
Talia Cucina RosticceriaPrice: Moderate• Italian• Downtown
•
4.7
J
Jim
Pittsburgh / Western PA •1 review
5.0
Dined 3 days ago
If you are looking for an enjoyable dining experience there is no better place than Alla Famiglia. From the great food to the incredible wine selection to the ambiance and of course service you won't be disappointed in anyway.
More info
Alla FamigliaPrice: Very Expensive• Italian• South Side
•
4.9
P
Paula
Pittsburgh / Western PA •46 reviews
5.0
Dined 5 days ago
Service was excellent and the food was outstanding. They had a gluten free pasta for one of us and my pasta was delicious. Our other diner really liked the chicken parm.
More info
Alta Via - Market SquarePrice: Expensive• Italian• Downtown
•
4.5
J
Josephvip
Pittsburgh / Western PA •70 reviews
5.0
Dined on 16 Nov 2024
AWESOME! We enjoyed a great dinner last night at Mezzo! We hadn't been there in a while. Since our last visit some new things were added to the menu and we decided to try three of them. We had the small plates of the lump crab cakes, and short rib and we shared the gnocchi with vodka sauce! The crab cakes were delicious and the side of aioli really made them shine! The short rib, bar none, was literally melt-in-your-mouth spectacular!!!!! The vodka sauce on the gnocchi had a hint of "spice" and the wilted spinach in the sauce made for another fabulous dish!!! A shout out to Jeffrey our server to Mike the manager and a BIG SHOUT OUT to the kitchen!!! Great job everyone!! Many thanks from this foodie!!!
More info
Mezzo at Sienna Mercato - Second Floor OnlyPrice: Expensive• Contemporary Italian• Downtown
•
4.3

Explore OpenTable

Bentleyville

Italian

Best Italian Restaurants in Bentleyville

Price

Regions

Areas

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Accessibility

26 restaurants available nearby

1. Mezzo at Sienna Mercato - Second Floor Only

2. Alla Famiglia

3. Pizzaiolo Primo - Market Square

4. Alta Via - Market Square

5. Talia Cucina Rosticceria

6. Vallozzi's Pittsburgh

7. Emerson’s

8. Fish nor Fowl

9. Martorano's Prime Pittsburgh

10. Alfabeto

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable