Best Italian Restaurants in Bayville

We love this restaurant. Our server was EXCELLENT. (Sadly, I cannot recall his name) I had the filet which was every bit as good as the restaurant across the street if not better. My dining mates had the duck , which was excellent. Normally we get the paella but decided to try other entrees. We shared the artichoke and French pizza. Which were also very tasty. Honestly, you can’t go wrong here.

Stellina is not your typical crowded Long Island Italian eatery where people go to be seen. Instead, it's like a café in Italy. The ambiance is wonderful, and the staff is easy to talk to and incredibly accommodating, taking care of special requests without hesitation. The food is fantastic—from the salads and wood-fired oven pizzas to the homemade pastas, Zuppe di Pesce, and lasagna. Stellina is worth the drive to Oyster Bay and is a standout.

Food and service was very good. Had to wait 25 minutes for table to free up even though we had a reservation. Went to bar to have a drink, martinis. Not impressed with the experience. Only had 2 brand options, Tito's or Kettle One. Serving was rather ordinary, olives were rather ordinary, no blue cheese option, and very pricey for the end product ($22 each). Wine at dinner was good, though. But, will go back again, and omit the martinis.

Two25 a Favorite. The only restaurant my 4 yr old grandson eats!! Always a wonderful dining experience.

We had the best time. The servers were amazing. Very friendly and attentive staff. We ordered a few items since we were not sure of the sizes and each thing, we ordered was exceptional. It was more than enough. I highly recommend the truffle mac cheese, meatball and flatbread pizza. Although really everything we had was great. The staff could not be more accommodating and welcoming. We loved that they had some special holiday drinks and were made to perfection. We are locals and always looking for something different in the area and this definitely is! Great addition to our town.