Enable JavaScript to run this app.
Skip to main content
OpenTable logo
  1. Home
  2. United States
  3. New York State

Best Italian Restaurants in Bay Shore

Price
Regions
Areas
Top Rated
Dining Options
Seating Options
Accessibility

19 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Butera's Restaurant of Bay Shore restaurant
1. Butera's Restaurant of Bay Shore
4.7
Exceptional(1017)
Price: Moderate
• Italian • Bay Shore
Booked 12 times today
Butera's Restaurant of Bay Shore offers a delightful experience of American cuisine that truly stands out. Nestled in the heart of Bay Shore, this charming eatery is celebrated for its "consistently delicious" dishes and "generous portions" that leave diners "extremely happy with their choices." The vibrant ambiance, enhanced by live music on select nights, creates a fun and upbeat dining environment. The attentive staff and personable service add a personal touch, ensuring every guest feels at home. With standout favorites like the Chicken Piccata and Pork Chop, Butera's promises an "11 out of 10" dining experience that never disappoints.
A photo of ITA Kitchen restaurant
2. ITA Kitchen
4.4
Awesome(972)
Price: Expensive
• Italian • Bay Shore
Booked 32 times today
ITA Kitchen in Bay Shore redefines what it means to enjoy authentic American cuisine, presented with a delightful Italian twist. Diners rave about the "outstanding food and wonderful service," making it a standout destination for those seeking a memorable dining experience. Reviews highlight the restaurant's innovative take on traditional dishes, such as the "phenomenal table-side mozzarella" and "amazing chicken picante," reflecting a creative fusion that respects classic American flavors. The vibrant atmosphere, coupled with enthusiastic and attentive staff, ensures that every visit is not just a meal but a celebration, making ITA Kitchen a must-visit for American cuisine enthusiasts.
A photo of Primi Italian Steakhouse restaurant
3. Primi Italian Steakhouse
4.8
Exceptional(1484)
Price: Very Expensive
• Italian • West Islip
Booked 19 times today
Primi Italian Steakhouse in West Islip masterfully blends authentic Italian fare with exquisite dry-aged prime steaks, creating a dining experience that’s nothing short of spectacular. This Steakhouse stands out for its “amazingly delicious food” and “top notch” service, as highlighted by numerous guests. Diners rave about the “bone-in veal chop to die for” and NY strip “cooked to perfection.” The ambiance, whether you're in the main dining room or cozy by the fireplace, adds to the allure. With an impressive wine selection and a vibrant atmosphere, Primi Italian Steakhouse is the perfect destination for an unforgettable steakhouse experience.
A photo of Bella Vie restaurant
4. Bella Vie
4.4
Awesome(566)
Price: Moderate
• Italian • Bay Shore
Booked 1 time today
Bella Vie is a beacon of exquisite French cuisine nestled in the heart of Bay Shore. This waterfront gem is celebrated for its authentic French flavors and award-winning romantic ambiance. Diners rave about the "delicious food and drinks" and the impeccable service that accompanies each meal. The prix fixe menu offers a delightful selection of French classics, ensuring a memorable dining experience. With stunning views of the lake, Bella Vie creates an enchanting atmosphere perfect for any occasion. Patrons frequently express their intent to return, highlighting the restaurant's consistent ability to impress, with remarks such as "Food and service were spectacular."
A photo of Marys Pizza & Restaurant restaurant
5. Marys Pizza & Restaurant
4.7
Exceptional(49)
Price: Moderate
• Italian • East Islip
Mary's Pizza & Restaurant in East Islip is a hidden gem for seafood lovers, offering a delightful array of authentic Italian seafood dishes that are sure to impress. Diners rave about the "fresh and very tasty" seafood, served in generous portions that leave you with leftovers to enjoy at home. The welcoming atmosphere and attentive service enhance the dining experience, making it a favorite spot for family gatherings and special occasions. Whether you're indulging in a new seafood creation or savoring a classic favorite, Mary's promises a memorable culinary journey that "never disappoints," securing its place as a neighborhood gem.
A photo of One10 Modern Italian restaurant
6. One10 Modern Italian
4.5
Awesome(2851)
Price: Very Expensive
• Italian • Melville
Booked 29 times today
One10 Modern Italian in Melville offers a delightful Mediterranean dining experience that is both authentic and innovative. Diners rave about the restaurant's "phenomenal" food and "impeccable" service, ensuring a memorable visit every time. The luxurious ambiance, adorned with copper, marble, and leather, sets the stage for a sophisticated meal. Featuring handcrafted pastas and fresh seafood, One10 seamlessly blends traditional Mediterranean flavors with modern twists. Guests are consistently impressed by the "outstandingly delicious" menu recommendations and the attentive staff, making it a top choice for Mediterranean cuisine. Experience the "amazing" flavors and exceptional service that make One10 a standout destination.
A photo of Osteria Umbra restaurant
7. Osteria Umbra
4.8
Exceptional(1914)
Price: Expensive
• Italian • Smithtown
Booked 23 times today
Italian hospitality and culinary traditions come together at Osteria UmbraExecutive Chef Marco Pellegrini & his wife, Chef de Cuisine, Sabrina Vallorini transport you to their hometown of Foligno, Umbria where quality craftsmanship and a deep respect for natural ingredients are woven into daily culture.At Osteria Umbra, Chef Marco Pellegrini has created an experience inspired by classic Umbrian cuisine, elevated by his attention to detail and culinary innovation.Each dish is handmade with the world’s finest ingredients; from the farms right here in our backyard to the rolling hills of Italy.This vision would not be possible without Stephen and Diane Bragoli & Daniel Bragoli, lover of all things food and wine.It is their attention to detail that creates a comfortable ambiance that represents the contemporary Italy of today combined with Chef Marco’s soulful cuisine that Osteria Umbra is born.
A photo of Smithtown Pasta House restaurant
8. Smithtown Pasta House
4.5
Awesome(361)
Price: Moderate
• Italian • Smithtown
Booked 9 times today
Smithtown Pasta House is a delightful gem in Smithtown, where the charm of American cuisine is celebrated with a unique Italian twist. Despite its name, this establishment is praised for its authentic American dining experience, offering “phenomenal food, service, and atmosphere.” Guests consistently rave about the “delicious meals” and “extraordinary” dining experiences, highlighting the restaurant as a neighborhood favorite. With its cozy ambiance and friendly staff, it embodies the warmth of an American family gathering. The generous portions and diverse menu options, including gluten-free choices, ensure that every visit feels like a special occasion. “Highly recommend” this gem for a memorable American dining experience!
A photo of Steve's Piccola Bussola of Hauppauge restaurant
9. Steve's Piccola Bussola of Hauppauge
4.7
Exceptional(537)
Price: Expensive
• Italian • Hauppauge
Booked 10 times today
At Steve's Piccola Bussola of Hauppauge, the fish dishes are truly a standout, earning rave reviews for their "scrumptious" flavors and freshness. Nestled in Hauppauge, this Italian gem is celebrated for its authentic and quality fish cuisine. Diners rave about the "special pasta with crab meat and shrimp," which captures the essence of Italian coastal flavors with finesse. It's no wonder patrons return time and again, as the restaurant consistently delivers "amazing" meals that are both delicious and memorable. If you're craving authentic Italian fish dishes, Steve's Piccola Bussola promises an "outstanding" dining experience that you won’t soon forget.
A photo of Trento Italian Steak House restaurant
10. Trento Italian Steak House
4.7
Exceptional(1724)
Price: Very Expensive
• Italian • Farmingdale
Booked 12 times today
Trento Italian Steak House in Farmingdale is a gem for lovers of authentic Italian cuisine. Known for its “outstanding food and impeccable service,” Trento consistently delivers an exceptional dining experience. The Branchinelli family’s dedication to quality is evident in their homemade pasta and prime aged steaks, crafted under the expertise of Executive Chef Edwin Leone. Guests rave about the “spectacular presentation” and flavors that transport them straight to Italy. With an inviting atmosphere and attentive staff, Trento is always a favorite for both intimate dinners and family gatherings. Whether it’s your first visit or your fiftieth, “Trento never disappoints.”

How is content generated

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you
From verified diners like you

Discover best Italian restaurants in Bay Shore

Discover the essence of Italian cuisine in Bay Shore, Suffolk, where a variety of restaurants offer an authentic taste of Italy right in the heart of New York State. Each establishment boasts unique interpretations of classic Italian dishes, blending traditional flavors with local ingredients to create mouth-watering menus that cater to all palates. From rustic, cozy atmospheres to modern, elegant settings, the dining scene in Bay Shore provides an ideal backdrop for both casual and sophisticated dining experiences. Patrons can expect top-notch service, high-quality food, and an ambiance that complements the rich, culinary heritage of Italy. Whether you're in the mood for hearty pasta, exquisite seafood, or a fine wine selection, Bay Shore's Italian restaurants promise a memorable dining experience. Embrace the local love for Italian cuisine in this vibrant community, where every meal is served with a touch of Italian hospitality.

Explore OpenTable

Discover
OpenTable
  • About Us
  • Blog
  • Careers
  • Press
More
Our sites
Businesses
  • Delight more diners
  • Open for Business Blog
Join us on
  • Privacy policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Cookies and Interest-Based Ads
  • Cookie Preferences
Copyright © 2024 OpenTable Australia Level 22, 357 Collins Street, Melbourne, Victoria - All rights reserved.
OpenTable is part of Booking Holdings, the world leader in online travel and related services.
Booking Logo
Priceline Logo
KAYAK Logo
Agoda Logo
OpenTable Logo