5 Best Continental Restaurants In Fishers Island

5 restaurants available nearby

1. The James

4.6

Exceptional(321)

Price: Very Expensive

• Continental • Babylon

Booked 70 times today

The James in Babylon is a stellar example of high-quality American cuisine. With an ambiance that "pays homage to the Carriage House," this elegant restaurant impresses with its attention to detail and impeccable service. Diners rave about the USDA Prime-grade steaks, fresh pastas, and locally sourced seafood, describing the food as "absolutely delicious" and "prepared to perfection." The atmosphere is vibrant yet welcoming, making it ideal for special occasions or a delightful night out. The James is more than just a meal; it's an experience that leaves guests eagerly planning their next visit, with many saying, "We will definitely be returning!"

A photo of Polo Lounge at the Westbury Manor restaurant

2. Polo Lounge at the Westbury Manor

4.8

Exceptional(272)

Price: Expensive

• Continental • Westbury

Booked 4 times today

Polo Lounge at the Westbury Manor is a seafood lover's paradise, offering an exquisite dining experience in the heart of Westbury. Renowned for its "incredible lobster" and perfectly prepared seafood dishes, this restaurant consistently delivers fresh, high-quality ingredients that delight the palate. The intimate dining room, paired with exceptional service from the likes of Frank, Oscar, and Mike, elevates each visit to a memorable occasion. Diners rave about the "scrumptious" offerings and the "beautifully presented" seafood, ensuring that every meal is both a visual and culinary delight. For an authentic and superior seafood experience, Polo Lounge is a must-visit.

3. Davenport Press

4.7

Exceptional(522)

Price: Very Expensive

• Continental • Mineola

Booked 12 times today

Davenport Press, a Mineola gem, has consistently delighted diners with its exquisite Continental cuisine since 1977. Nestled in a historic Long Island landmark, this restaurant offers a menu that is both expansive and meticulously curated, ensuring “something for everyone.” The authenticity and quality of its dishes are evident in glowing reviews, with patrons praising the “delicious food, ginormous portions,” and “stellar specials menu.” Each visit is a memorable experience, thanks to the “outstanding service” and “charming ambiance.” Whether celebrating a special occasion or enjoying a quiet dinner, Davenport Press promises an unparalleled dining experience that keeps guests returning for more.

A photo of Rialto -Carle Place New York restaurant

4. Rialto -Carle Place New York

4.7

Exceptional(842)

Price: Expensive

• Continental • Carle Place

Booked 4 times today

Rialto in Carle Place offers a sublime Italian dining experience, expertly crafted by Owner and Chef Fabio Ventura. Boasting an enticing blend of contemporary American and Mediterranean flavors, the restaurant’s commitment to quality is evident in its homemade pasta and fresh seafood creations. Guests rave about the “exceptional Italian food” and praise Rialto as “one of the best restaurants on Long Island.” The charming ambiance—enhanced by a recent renovation—paired with attentive service ensures an unforgettable visit. With delectable desserts like tiramisu and an impressive wine list, Rialto is a true “hidden gem” that promises a delightful culinary journey.

A photo of Harbor Mist Restaurant restaurant

5. Harbor Mist Restaurant

4.7

Exceptional(1337)

Price: Expensive

• Continental • Cold Spring Harbor

Booked 3 times today

Harbor Mist Restaurant in Cold Spring Harbor offers an exceptional Italian dining experience, celebrated for its authentic and high-quality Italian cuisine. Diners rave about its “best seafood Fra Diavolo on the island” and the “delicious halibut dish,” which highlight the restaurant's commitment to freshness and flavor. The picturesque views of Cold Spring Harbor add to the enchanting ambiance, making each visit memorable. With a menu that beautifully blends classic Italian flavors with local seafood, Harbor Mist stands out as a must-visit destination for Italian food lovers. The attentive service and welcoming atmosphere ensure guests feel like cherished family.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

Best Continental Restaurants in Fishers Island

Price

Regions

Areas

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Accessibility

5 restaurants available nearby

1. The James

2. Polo Lounge at the Westbury Manor

3. Davenport Press

4. Rialto -Carle Place New York

5. Harbor Mist Restaurant

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable