Enable JavaScript to run this app.
Skip to main content
OpenTable logo
  1. Home
  2. United States
  3. New York City

Best Contemporary Italian Restaurants in Sheepshead Bay

Price
Regions
Areas
Top Rated
Dining Options
Seating Options
Award-winning
Accessibility

18 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Gargiulo's Coney Island restaurant
1. Gargiulo's Coney Island
4.7
Exceptional(813)
Price: Expensive
• Contemporary italian • Coney Island
Booked 7 times today
Gargiulo's Coney Island offers an authentic journey into the heart of Contemporary Italian cuisine right in Brooklyn. Known for its "divine" traditional Neapolitan fare, Gargiulo’s combines family recipes that have delighted diners since 1907 with a modern twist. The restaurant is celebrated for its "phenomenal" dishes like pan-seared mozzarella and trofie pasta with pesto, which highlight the fresh, high-quality ingredients and meticulous preparation. Guests rave about the "exceptional service" and the warm, welcoming atmosphere that makes every visit feel like dining with family. With its rich history and dedication to culinary excellence, Gargiulo’s is a cherished gem that continues to impress.
A photo of Malone's Chop House restaurant
2. Malone's Chop House
4.5
Awesome(71)
Price: Expensive
• Contemporary italian • Bay Ridge
Booked 2 times today
Malone's Chop House in Bay Ridge, Brooklyn, is a beacon of exceptional Contemporary Italian cuisine, where the culinary expertise of three seasoned chefs with over 60 years of combined experience shines. Guests rave about the "phenomenal" food and "impeccable" service, noting that every dish, from the grilled octopus to the exquisite filet mignon, is a testament to their culinary prowess. The ambiance is both welcoming and vibrant, offering a perfect setting for a memorable dining experience. With a menu that surprises and delights, Malone's Chop House is a must-visit destination for those seeking an authentic taste of Contemporary Italian cuisine.
A photo of Cecconi's Dumbo restaurant
3. Cecconi's Dumbo
4.6
Exceptional(5287)
Price: Moderate
• Contemporary italian • DUMBO
Booked 173 times today
Cecconi's Dumbo, located in the heart of Brooklyn's DUMBO neighborhood, offers an exceptional Mediterranean dining experience with a focus on authentic Italian cuisine. Guests rave about the “stunning views” of the Manhattan skyline and the Brooklyn Bridge, which enhance the lively yet elegant atmosphere. The restaurant is praised for its “delicious, creative twists on Italian classics,” such as the truffled whipped ricotta and hand-made pasta, making each dish a delightful journey through Mediterranean flavors. With “fantastic service” and an inviting ambiance, Cecconi's Dumbo is a must-visit for those seeking a memorable blend of taste and scenery.
A photo of Café Mars restaurant
4. Café Mars
4.9
Exceptional(87)
Price: Very Expensive
• Contemporary italian • Park Slope
Booked 12 times today
Café Mars is an unusual Italian restaurant. Come see what we mean!For parties larger than 6 please email info@cafemarsbk.com to help craft your hassle free dining experience!
A photo of Il Mulino Prime - SoHo restaurant
5. Il Mulino Prime - SoHo
4.5
Awesome(720)
Price: Very Expensive
• Contemporary italian • SoHo
Booked 16 times today
Il Mulino Prime - SoHo offers an unparalleled experience in Contemporary Italian cuisine, nestled in the vibrant heart of SoHo, New York. With a commitment to quality and authenticity, the restaurant delights diners with dishes "better than Rome!" Guests rave about the "fantastic food" and "outstanding service," making each visit a memorable one. Whether you're savoring the impeccable spaghetti carbonara or indulging in the exquisite filet mignon paired with a fine Chianti, every meal is a celebration of flavors. The sophisticated yet inviting atmosphere, combined with attentive staff, ensures a "top-notch experience" perfect for any occasion. Come for the food, stay for the exceptional experience!
A photo of Maddy Rose at Liberty House restaurant
6. Maddy Rose at Liberty House
4.7
Exceptional(2220)
Price: Expensive
• Contemporary italian • Jersey City
Booked 13 times today
Maddy Rose at Liberty House is a standout destination for authentic Mediterranean cuisine in Jersey City, offering a culinary journey that transports diners to the sun-kissed beaches of Greece and Italy. The restaurant's menu, brimming with large shareable plates and exquisite tableside productions, showcases the true essence of Mediterranean flavors. Guests rave about the "absolutely delicious food" and "exceptional service," making every visit memorable. With its unmatched beverage program and stunning NYC skyline views, Maddy Rose creates a vibrant atmosphere perfect for any occasion. As one diner joyfully exclaimed, "This is our spot; I want to come here every month!"
A photo of Il Giglio restaurant
7. Il Giglio
4.8
Exceptional(137)
Price: Very Expensive
• Contemporary italian • TriBeCa
Booked 6 times today
Il Giglio in TriBeCa, New York, masterfully elevates Contemporary Italian cuisine with its "exquisite handmade pastas" and dishes that celebrate the bounty of Italy's land and sea. Diners are consistently impressed, describing the restaurant as a "true gem" with "spectacular food" and an "impressive wine selection" that transports you straight to the Italian countryside. The ambiance is both chic and inviting, making it a perfect spot for a sophisticated dinner or a lively brunch. With a team that offers "outstanding service," Il Giglio ensures that every visit is a memorable celebration of Italian culinary elegance.
A photo of Osteria Barocca restaurant
8. Osteria Barocca
4.1
Excellent(127)
Price: Moderate
• Contemporary italian • Little Italy
Booked 12 times today
Osteria Barocca in Little Italy, New York, offers an exquisite Mediterranean dining experience that is both authentic and unforgettable. Known for its "outstanding food and impeccable service," this restaurant seamlessly combines classic Italian specialties with a contemporary twist, ensuring every dish is a culinary delight. Reviewers rave about the "bold flavors" and fresh ingredients, particularly praising the homemade pasta and delectable seafood. The ambiance is described as "elegant and cozy," providing the perfect backdrop for a memorable meal. With a passionate staff that makes diners feel at home, Osteria Barocca is a must-visit for an authentic taste of the Mediterranean.
A photo of Fiat Cafe restaurant
9. Fiat Cafe
4.7
Exceptional(267)
Price: Moderate
• Contemporary italian • NoLita
Booked 14 times today
Fiat Cafe, located in the heart of Nolita, New York, offers an authentic taste of American cuisine with an Italian twist, making it a true gem in the city. The restaurant boasts "delicious food, great services, and lovely staff," creating a welcoming and friendly atmosphere for all its guests. Known for its unique decor featuring colorful Fiat 500 cars, Fiat Cafe provides a cozy and charming setting for any meal. Diners rave about the "absolutely amazing experience" they have here, with the service and food consistently praised as excellent. Whether you're stopping by for breakfast, brunch, lunch, or dinner, Fiat Cafe promises "a great value" with its moderately priced and delectable dishes.
A photo of Patrizias of Brooklyn restaurant
10. Patrizias of Brooklyn
4.4
Awesome(414)
Price: Expensive
• Contemporary italian • Williamsburg
Booked 20 times today
Patrizias of Brooklyn stands out as a beacon of Contemporary Italian cuisine, nestled in the vibrant neighborhood of Williamsburg. Known for its "amazing home-cooked feel," Patrizias channels the essence of Italian tradition through its delectable dishes, crafted from fresh, organic ingredients and family recipes dating back over 150 years. The atmosphere is described as "energetic" and reminiscent of a "family reunion at grandma's," making diners feel warmly welcomed and celebrated. Patrizias truly shines with its impeccable service, generous portions, and delicious pizzas and pastas, ensuring every visit is a memorable experience. Patrizias is a must-visit for those seeking authentic Italian flair!

How is content generated

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you
From verified diners like you

Discover best Contemporary Italian restaurants in Sheepshead Bay

Discover the vibrant culinary scene of Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn, with our curated collection of contemporary Italian restaurants. Nestled in this scenic waterfront neighborhood of New York City, these establishments offer a delightful blend of modern Italian dishes that cater to both traditional and innovative palates. Each restaurant showcases a commitment to quality and authenticity, featuring menus rich with fresh seafood, exquisite pasta dishes, and inventive Italian cuisine that reflect the dynamic food culture of the area. Patrons can expect top-notch service and an inviting atmosphere that complements the meticulously prepared dishes. As a hub for culinary creativity, Sheepshead Bay provides a unique dining experience, enhancing the charm of Brooklyn's diverse food landscape. Whether you're a local or a visitor, these contemporary Italian eateries promise an unforgettable gastronomic adventure in one of the city's most picturesque locales.

Explore OpenTable

Discover
OpenTable
  • About Us
  • Blog
  • Careers
  • Press
More
Our sites
Businesses
  • Delight more diners
  • Open for Business Blog
Join us on
  • Privacy policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Cookies and Interest-Based Ads
  • Cookie Preferences
Copyright © 2024 OpenTable Australia Level 22, 357 Collins Street, Melbourne, Victoria - All rights reserved.
OpenTable is part of Booking Holdings, the world leader in online travel and related services.
Booking Logo
Priceline Logo
KAYAK Logo
Agoda Logo
OpenTable Logo