Enable JavaScript to run this app.
Skip to main content
OpenTable logo
  1. Home
  2. United States
  3. New York City

Best Contemporary Italian Restaurants in Sheepshead Bay

Price
Regions
Areas
Top Rated
Dining Options
Seating Options
Award-winning
Accessibility

18 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Gargiulo's Coney Island restaurant
1. Gargiulo's Coney Island
4.9
Exceptional(803)
Price: Expensive
• Contemporary italian • Coney Island
Booked 3 times today
At Gargiulo's Coney Island, nestled in the vibrant heart of Brooklyn, you'll discover a slice of Italy renowned for its authenticity and rich tradition. Celebrated for its "divine" Italian cuisine, Gargiulo’s serves up traditional Neapolitan dishes crafted from family recipes that have been cherished since 1907. Patrons rave about the "outstanding" Trofie pasta with pesto and the "perfect" lamb chops, highlighting the fresh, high-quality ingredients. The atmosphere is described as an "Italian villa," adding to the authentic experience. As one reviewer put it, the house-made cannoli is "out of this world," making Gargiulo's a must-visit for anyone seeking the true essence of Italian dining in New York City.
A photo of Malone's Chop House restaurant
2. Malone's Chop House
4.6
Exceptional(70)
Price: Expensive
• Contemporary italian • Bay Ridge
Booked 3 times today
Malone's Chop House, nestled in the heart of Bay Ridge, Brooklyn, offers a stellar Contemporary Italian dining experience that stands out for its quality and authenticity. With three chefs boasting a combined 60 years of fine dining expertise, Malone's serves up Italian cuisine with a modern twist that consistently impresses. Diners rave about the perfectly cooked filet mignon and grilled octopus, highlighting dishes like the "delicious" potato pie and the "fabulous" steak. The restaurant's atmosphere and service receive equal praise, described as "impeccable" and "attentive," making every meal memorable. As one satisfied guest puts it, "Malone's is a must-go-to restaurant!" This spot is a gem for those seeking exquisite Contemporary Italian fare in Brooklyn.
A photo of Cecconi's Dumbo restaurant
3. Cecconi's Dumbo
4.5
Awesome(5207)
Price: Moderate
• Contemporary italian • DUMBO
Booked 188 times today
Cecconi's Dumbo, nestled in the picturesque DUMBO neighborhood of Brooklyn, offers a sublime Mediterranean dining experience that harmonizes beautifully with its stunning waterfront views of the Manhattan skyline. This restaurant is celebrated for its "delicious Mediterranean classics like the Roman style gnocchi and risotto" that transport diners straight to Italy with each bite. Reviewers consistently rave about the authenticity and quality of the cuisine, noting dishes like "octopus, tuna tartare Cecconi’s style, and zucchini Fritti" as must-tries. A guest highlighted, "If you wanna taste real Italian food, this is the place!" With its "fabulous view and great service," Cecconi's Dumbo promises not just a meal, but a memorable Mediterranean feast that's always "on point."
A photo of Café Mars restaurant
4. Café Mars
4.9
Exceptional(80)
Price: Very Expensive
• Contemporary italian • Park Slope
Café Mars is an unusual Italian restaurant. Come see what we mean!For parties larger than 6 please email info@cafemarsbk.com to help craft your hassle free dining experience!
A photo of Maddy Rose at Liberty House restaurant
5. Maddy Rose at Liberty House
4.7
Exceptional(2201)
Price: Expensive
• Contemporary italian • Jersey City
Booked 10 times today
Maddy Rose at Liberty House in Liberty State Park, Jersey City, offers a sublime Contemporary Italian dining experience that stands out for its quality and authenticity. Patrons rave about the "state of the art tableside productions" and dishes that make you "feel that you could be on the beaches of Italy." The restaurant's commitment to crafting exceptional culinary creations is evident, with reviews noting the food is "outstanding" and "divine, with each dish a masterpiece of flavor and presentation." The atmosphere enhances the experience, boasting "unbeatable views of the NYC skyline" and an ambiance that is both "modern and inviting." Whether it’s the "splendid tomahawk" or the "perfectly peppered broccolini," Maddy Rose promises a memorable meal that brings a taste of Italy to Jersey City.
A photo of Il Mulino Prime - SoHo restaurant
6. Il Mulino Prime - SoHo
4.7
Exceptional(706)
Price: Very Expensive
• Contemporary italian • SoHo
Booked 13 times today
Il Mulino Prime, nestled in the vibrant SoHo neighborhood of New York, epitomizes exceptional Steakhouse cuisine with a touch of Italian flair. Renowned for its "perfect steak" and ambience that's "sophisticated by night," Il Mulino Prime offers a culinary experience that is both authentic and memorable. Guests rave about the "unforgettable" porterhouse steak and the "amazing" New York strip, highlighting the quality and preparation that make each visit spectacular. With praise like "the food was aaammaazing" and descriptions of experiences that are "truly worth every penny," it's clear this steakhouse stands out in the bustling NYC culinary scene. Enthusiasts of fine dining and high-quality steaks will find Il Mulino Prime a must-visit destination.
A photo of Osteria Barocca restaurant
7. Osteria Barocca
4.3
Awesome(112)
Price: Moderate
• Contemporary italian • Little Italy
Booked 16 times today
Step into Osteria Barocca in the heart of Little Italy, New York, and experience the epitome of Mediterranean cuisine. This Italian fine dining establishment blends classic and modern styles to create dishes that are both authentic and innovative. Guests rave about the "exceptional spicy rigatoni" and "delightful fried calamari," noting that each dish bursts with freshness and flavor. The atmosphere is described as "elegant and cozy," perfect for any memorable dining occasion. Reviewers consistently highlight the "impeccable service," with staff like Barisa and Iman going above and beyond to enhance the dining experience. Whether you're a local or a visitor, Osteria Barocca promises an unforgettable Mediterranean feast in an inviting setting.
A photo of Il Giglio restaurant
8. Il Giglio
4.8
Exceptional(121)
Price: Very Expensive
• Contemporary italian • TriBeCa
Booked 15 times today
Il Giglio, nestled in the heart of TriBeCa, New York, is a beacon of contemporary Italian cuisine that effortlessly blends tradition with modern elegance. Celebrated for its "exquisite handmade pastas" and "lovingly crafted plates," this chic dining spot captivates with its authenticity and culinary creativity. Patrons rave about the "best chicken parm ever had" and the "out of this world homemade gnocchi," highlighting Il Giglio's commitment to quality and flavor. The restaurant's extensive selection of regional wines and vibrant aperitivo culture further enrich the dining experience, making every visit memorable. As one reviewer puts it, Il Giglio is "the best Italian food I know of in New York City," a testament to its exceptional dishes and impeccable service that make it a must-visit destination for anyone seeking the finest in contemporary Italian fare.
A photo of Patrizias of Brooklyn restaurant
9. Patrizias of Brooklyn
4.5
Awesome(408)
Price: Expensive
• Contemporary italian • Williamsburg
Booked 12 times today
Patrizia's of Brooklyn is not just a restaurant; it’s an embodiment of authentic Italian culture and exquisite Pizzeria cuisine located in the heart of Williamsburg. Celebrating over 25 years of family tradition, Patrizia’s delights diners with dishes crafted from recipes passed down for generations, ensuring each bite is steeped in history and flavor. Guests rave about the "classic NY experience" with "excellent pizza" that is both "tasty" and "large in portion," making every meal a culinary adventure. The atmosphere is described as "very welcoming," where every guest is treated like family, enhancing the dining experience with warmth and genuine hospitality. Whether you're there for a slice of their celebrated pizza or to enjoy the lively ambiance, Patrizia’s promises an unforgettable visit with every dish served.
A photo of Fiat Cafe restaurant
10. Fiat Cafe
4.7
Exceptional(264)
Price: Moderate
• Contemporary italian • NoLita
Booked 4 times today
Fiat Cafe in NoLita, New York, is a delightful haven for American cuisine enthusiasts. This cozy cafe, celebrated for its authenticity and quality, serves a spectrum of American classics that have patrons raving about their culinary experiences. Diners especially adore their fluffy pancakes, French toast, and the spinach and goat cheese omelet, describing them as "to die for." The atmosphere is praised for being "cozy and welcoming," making it a perfect spot for both quick bites and leisurely meals. With glowing reviews, such as "the best BLT sandwich I’ve ever had" and "phenomenal service," Fiat Cafe stands out as a must-visit for those seeking a genuine taste of American comfort food in a charming neighborhood setting.

How is content generated

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you
From verified diners like you

Discover best Contemporary Italian restaurants in Sheepshead Bay

Discover the vibrant culinary scene of Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn, with our curated collection of contemporary Italian restaurants. Nestled in this scenic waterfront neighborhood of New York City, these establishments offer a delightful blend of modern Italian dishes that cater to both traditional and innovative palates. Each restaurant showcases a commitment to quality and authenticity, featuring menus rich with fresh seafood, exquisite pasta dishes, and inventive Italian cuisine that reflect the dynamic food culture of the area. Patrons can expect top-notch service and an inviting atmosphere that complements the meticulously prepared dishes. As a hub for culinary creativity, Sheepshead Bay provides a unique dining experience, enhancing the charm of Brooklyn's diverse food landscape. Whether you're a local or a visitor, these contemporary Italian eateries promise an unforgettable gastronomic adventure in one of the city's most picturesque locales.

Explore OpenTable

Discover
OpenTable
  • About Us
  • Blog
  • Careers
  • Press
More
Our sites
Businesses
  • Delight more diners
Join us on
  • Privacy policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Cookies and Interest-Based Ads
  • Cookie Preferences
Copyright © 2024 OpenTable Australia Level 22, 357 Collins Street, Melbourne, Victoria - All rights reserved.
OpenTable is part of Booking Holdings, the world leader in online travel and related services.
Booking Logo
Priceline Logo
KAYAK Logo
Agoda Logo
OpenTable Logo