Enable JavaScript to run this app.
Skip to main content
OpenTable logo
  1. Home
  2. United States
  3. New York City

Best Comfort Food Restaurants in Sheepshead Bay

Price
Regions
Areas
Top Rated
Dining Options
Seating Options
Award-winning
Accessibility

17 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Gargiulo's Coney Island restaurant
1. Gargiulo's Coney Island
4.9
Exceptional(803)
Price: Expensive
• Comfort food • Coney Island
Booked 6 times today
At Gargiulo's Coney Island, nestled in the vibrant heart of Brooklyn, you'll discover a slice of Italy renowned for its authenticity and rich tradition. Celebrated for its "divine" Italian cuisine, Gargiulo’s serves up traditional Neapolitan dishes crafted from family recipes that have been cherished since 1907. Patrons rave about the "outstanding" Trofie pasta with pesto and the "perfect" lamb chops, highlighting the fresh, high-quality ingredients. The atmosphere is described as an "Italian villa," adding to the authentic experience. As one reviewer put it, the house-made cannoli is "out of this world," making Gargiulo's a must-visit for anyone seeking the true essence of Italian dining in New York City.
A photo of SET L.E.S. restaurant
2. SET L.E.S.
4.6
Exceptional(97)
Price: Moderate
• Comfort food • Lower East Side
Booked 5 times today
Immerse yourself in a vibrant burst of Asian flavors at SET L.E.S., a celebrated hotspot in the pulsating heart of New York's Lower East Side. Known for its Asian-inspired menu, this locale dazzles with dishes that are both innovative and comforting. Patrons rave about the authenticity and creativity of the menu, highlighting favorites like the "Thai chili siracha wings" that are a must-try for spicy food lovers. As one enthusiast puts it, "The wings are absolutely incredible, and don't even get me started on the chicken and waffles or the steak and eggs — they're all amazing!" SET L.E.S. not only promises an electrifying atmosphere but also an unforgettable dining experience that keeps locals and visitors coming back for more.
A photo of Island Rib House restaurant
3. Island Rib House
4.5
Awesome(0)
Price: Expensive
• Comfort food • Crown Heights
Booked 1 time today
At Island Rib House in Crown Heights, immerse yourself in authentic Caribbean flavors that consistently impress. Diners rave about the "fall off the bone perfection" of both beef and pork ribs, and the Jerk Salmon and Oxtail Island Fried Rice are neighborhood favorites. Not just for the food, but Island Rib House is also celebrated for its "phenomenal food & amazing bar service," perfect for any food lover looking to experience true Caribbean zest. The inviting atmosphere and friendly staff make every visit memorable, with guests often highlighting the exceptional service and "delicious and well-prepared" dishes. A must-visit spot for anyone craving genuine Caribbean cuisine in a welcoming environment.
A photo of Rustik Tavern restaurant
4. Rustik Tavern
4.7
Exceptional(21)
Price: Expensive
• Comfort food • Bedford-Stuyvesant
Rustik Tavern, nestled in the heart of Bedford-Stuyvesant, Brooklyn, is a beacon of American cuisine, offering an ambience reminiscent of mama's home-cooked meals but with a modern twist. Patrons rave about the authenticity and quality of the food, describing it as a "neighborhood gem" that feels like dining at a best friend's home. Highlights from the fiercely flavorful menu include "delicious" salmon burgers, "perfectly fried" chicken sandwiches, and the highly praised banana foster French toast. Reviews consistently applaud the "outstanding" service and the "strong" mimosas, making Rustik Tavern a must-visit for anyone seeking a genuine taste of Brooklyn's finest American fare.
A photo of Westville Dumbo restaurant
5. Westville Dumbo
4.5
Awesome(493)
Price: Moderate
• Comfort food • DUMBO
Booked 7 times today
Westville Dumbo in Brooklyn's vibrant DUMBO neighborhood is celebrated for its simple yet delightful vegetarian cuisine. Diners rave about the freshness and quality of dishes, with one customer exclaiming, "The food is always on point, tasty and fresh. It's delish!" The restaurant's commitment to vegetarian and vegan options is evident, with enthusiastic endorsements such as "Special shoutout for vegan dishes!" underscoring its appeal. The cozy atmosphere and friendly service complement the dining experience, making Westville Dumbo a must-visit for those seeking authentic and wholesome vegetarian meals. Whether you're local or just passing through, this gem offers a memorable culinary journey with its well-crafted vegetarian delights.
A photo of La Nonna Ristorante & Bar - Brooklyn restaurant
6. La Nonna Ristorante & Bar - Brooklyn
4.7
Exceptional(1189)
Price: Expensive
• Comfort food • Williamsburg
Booked 8 times today
At La Nonna Ristorante & Bar in Williamsburg, Brooklyn, you're promised an extraordinary dining experience that epitomizes the essence of contemporary Italian cuisine. Executive Chef Cono Morena, inspired by his childhood in Teggiano, Italy, crafts dishes that transport diners straight to Nonna’s table with each bite. The restaurant's ambiance, with its intimate candlelight and elegant drapes, complements the high-quality, authentic Italian dishes beautifully. Guests rave about the consistency and excellence of the food; one guest exclaimed it was the "best dining experience I’ve had in my life." Whether you're savoring the shrimp scampi, ravioli, or the praised branzino, La Nonna ensures a memorable meal with exceptional service in a truly welcoming setting.
A photo of Piccoli Trattoria restaurant
7. Piccoli Trattoria
4.8
Exceptional(291)
Price: Moderate
• Comfort food • Park Slope
Booked 4 times today
Piccoli Trattoria in Park Slope, Brooklyn, is a haven of authentic Italian cuisine that crafts each dish with an extraordinary blend of simplicity and quality. Celebrated for its homemade pasta and dishes like the "phenomenal" sweet corn ravioli and the "divine" burrata and salted beet salad, Piccoli elevates simple ingredients into a spectacular culinary experience. Using high-quality, locally sourced ingredients, and specialties imported directly from Italy like Prosciutto di Parma and buffalo mozzarella from Napoli, this restaurant ensures every meal is as genuine as it is delicious. Patrons consistently praise not only the food but the "excellent service and cozy ambiance," making Piccoli Trattoria a must-visit spot for Italian cuisine enthusiasts.
A photo of Urban Cove Society and Kitchen restaurant
8. Urban Cove Society and Kitchen
4.1
Excellent(30)
Price: Expensive
• Comfort food • Financial District
Booked 4 times today
Urban Cove Society and Kitchen, nestled within the vibrant Seaport District of New York City, offers a culinary nod to the metropolis's diverse cultural tapestry through its Global, International cuisine. Located in 33 Hotel, this dining gem intertwines Modern American flavors with global influences, creating dishes that are both comforting and exciting. Patrons rave about their dining experiences, highlighting not only the delicious food but also the exceptional service and ambiance. One review encapsulates the sentiment: "Everything about this place is amazing! Came here for my birthday and I am so glad I did!" Urban Cove is quickly becoming a beloved spot for those seeking a blend of culinary craftsmanship and a welcoming atmosphere.
A photo of Bogota Latin Bistro restaurant
9. Bogota Latin Bistro
4.7
Exceptional(1650)
Price: Moderate
• Comfort food • Park Slope
Booked 6 times today
Nestled in the heart of Park Slope, Brooklyn, Bogota Latin Bistro is a gem for anyone craving authentic Latin comfort food. This vibrant eatery specializes in Colombian classics like Bandeja Paisa and Arroz con Pollo, which are as comforting as they are delicious. Diners consistently rave about the "top-notch" service and the "amazing" atmosphere, making it not just a meal, but an experience. A patron enthused, "The best restaurant I've gone to in the United States if you've got an allergy or dietary restriction hands down!" With dishes crafted to accommodate various dietary needs, including a thoughtful gluten-free selection, Bogota Latin Bistro ensures every guest leaves satisfied. Whether you're popping in for their renowned happy hour or a leisurely brunch, expect a feast that feels like home, yet dazzles with its authenticity and flair.
A photo of Westville Wall Street restaurant
10. Westville Wall Street
4.7
Exceptional(239)
Price: Moderate
• Comfort food • Financial District
Booked 15 times today
Westville Wall Street in the Financial District is a haven for Vegetarian cuisine lovers. Patrons rave about the freshness and creativity of the dishes. One delighted diner shared, "The vegetable plates were so creative and delicious," highlighting the standout quality of their offerings. The restaurant is celebrated for its Market Plate, allowing guests to choose from an array of vibrant market vegetables. Reviewers consistently praise the variety and flavor, noting dishes like truffle parm fries, teriyaki tofu, and grilled peaches with feta. With its commitment to simple, delicious food, Westville Wall Street proves to be a top choice for anyone seeking exceptional vegetarian options in New York.
‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you
From verified diners like you

Explore OpenTable

Discover
OpenTable
  • About Us
  • Blog
  • Careers
  • Press
More
Our sites
Businesses
  • Delight more diners
Join us on
  • Privacy policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Cookies and Interest-Based Ads
  • Cookie Preferences
Copyright © 2024 OpenTable Australia Level 22, 357 Collins Street, Melbourne, Victoria - All rights reserved.
OpenTable is part of Booking Holdings, the world leader in online travel and related services.
Booking Logo
Priceline Logo
KAYAK Logo
Agoda Logo
OpenTable Logo