Best American Restaurants in Tomales

First time at Goldfinch and will definitely be back. First the staff accommodated us with a seating earlier than our reservation. We ate at the counter which was lively and fun. Great bartender who made me one of the best Paper Planes I’ve had. From there we had a delicious salad and then the hanger steak entree and both we excellent. A very enjoyable evening and look forward to returning soon.

Great food and wine.  The service was unobtrusive. The waiter was friendly. 

Excellent! We had the seafood stew, Shrimp Louie, tomato soup, and cheesy bread. So yummy! Loved the crushed ice in the drinks too.

Gem of a restaurant and bar in Sebastopol. Love the interior and consistently good service.

Christmas Eve dinner. Party of three. High satisfaction level, as usual! Stark’s Seafood and Steak is our holiday meal go to. I make the same thing every holiday…. reservations at Stark’s. Festive decorations, a welcoming holiday atmosphere. Our server was warm, affable, professional without hovering. Just right. We all ordered appetizers, and the mussels were the unanimous winner. Little ones in a sauce worthy of sopping up with a second order of bread. My daughter ordered her favorite butter fish with sticky rice and it met her expectations again. The other two of us had the lobster, so perfectly prepared. Again. Generous portions left us too full for dessert, and memories of a lovely holiday meal . Thank you.