Best American Restaurants in Ortley Beach

We absolutely enjoyed our dinner! We had the lobster tail and the pistachio crusted halibut, both were outstanding! Michele our waitress was nothing less then amazing!! Thank you for an amazing ing experience!

Amazing service, food, and ambience! Perfect for a special occasion!

We booked late for Valentine’s Day and could only get a high top at the bar. When the hostess called to confirm our reservation she was so kind and asked if we would prefer a regular table in the dining area and if something opened up she would put us in. When we got to the restaurant it was beautiful and decorated with a huge balloon shaped heart for pictures. We didn’t take any, but it was cute. lol. The hostess sat us in a beautifully decorated room, the tables were spaced perfectly so you weren’t sitting too close to anyone and had privacy for conversations. The waiter was very friendly and attentive as well as the runners. We ordered the charcuterie butcher block, seafood tower and hanger steak. Everything was cooked perfectly and served with perfect timing. We finished the meal with the cannoli dessert. The cannoli’s were delicious, and we are tough critics because we are Italian! Lol Bottoms line….. everything was perfect and we look forward to returning!

Always an amazing experience! The food is delicious and fresh!! Their style of cooking is made with love from old school recipes!! We have been here many times, as well as their storefront, Breakin Bread Eatery, for sandwiches, etc… You know you’re going to eat good here and roll yourself out to your car!! 😆 From the moment you walk in, you are always greeted with a warm and friendly hello and shown such appreciation and gratitude for supporting their business before you leave!! Thanks again Pete and Nicole for a wonderful night!! ❤️

My request for a table by the window was respected. Food is always fantastic. Its presentation is wonderful. Our waiter was very accommodating . One concern for me was that the Valentine’s Day menu had all seafood selections. I am not a seafood eater and my usual steak was not an option. While I love this restaurant I was disappointed with the lack of beef as a selection for this occasion.