Best American Restaurants in Marco Island

The food was excellent and our server Michaela was great.

Ordered the half rack of lamb and it was cooked perfectly med-rare. The portions were a bit small for the price but our entrees came with a tossed salad and delicious homemade bread that helped satisfy us. The white light bulbs in the ceiling need a better dimmer, it felt more like eating in a diner in the main dining room. Would rather a darker feel with perhaps small candles on each table to improve the ambiance.

The place was really active which is great to see! They have lovely craft cocktails and very good appetizers. We started with the grilled octopus which is served with grilled beets and goat cheese. It is a wonderful blend of flavors. My husband had blackened grouper and I had the dorado. Both were excellent. Our server Charla was a joy as usual! She checks with you to be sure you are ok but is not overly attentive. You get to enjoy your meal! I highly recommend Fin Bistro. Some night we're just going to come in to share some appetizers and then maybe we will have room to share a dessert!

The food was outstanding. And I asked for an unusual cocktail and the bartender made it perfectly! We all thanked the manager, chef and bartender for such a fun evening with great food and drinks.