5 Best American Restaurants In Key Colony Beach

5 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Angler & Ale at Hawks Cay restaurant

1. Angler & Ale at Hawks Cay

4.2

Price: Expensive

• American • Duck Key

Booked 43 times today

Angler & Ale at Hawks Cay is a seafood lover's paradise located in the stunning Duck Key. Renowned for its "absolutely delicious" and "fresh and delightful" seafood, diners are in for a treat with options like the "outstanding Tuna nachos" and "to die for red grouper." The restaurant's unique hook-and-cook offering lets you savor the freshest catch, expertly prepared by skilled chefs. With breathtaking marina views and a vibrant atmosphere, it's the perfect spot for a memorable dining experience. Guests rave about the "amazing dinner" and "fantastic food," making Angler & Ale a must-visit destination for authentic seafood cuisine.

A photo of Lighthouse Kitchen + Bar restaurant

2. Lighthouse Kitchen + Bar

4.1

Excellent(1230)

Price: Expensive

• American • Marathon

Booked 18 times today

Lighthouse Kitchen + Bar offers a seafood dining experience that's nothing short of exceptional. Nestled in Marathon, the restaurant shines with its fresh seafood creations, artfully capturing the essence of local flavors. Diners rave about the "catch of the day" offerings, like the exquisite mutton snapper, which one guest described as "amazing." The waterfront setting, under the historic Faro Blanco lighthouse, enhances the experience, creating a serene backdrop for a memorable meal. With attentive service and a menu that consistently delights, it's no wonder patrons return time and again to savor the "best meal on the island."

3. Butterfly Café

4.5

Awesome(452)

Price: Expensive

• American • Marathon

Booked 19 times today

Nestled in the picturesque bayside views of Marathon at Tranquility Bay, Butterfly Café offers an exquisite seafood dining experience that is truly second to none. Renowned for its "amazing seafood dishes and flavors," the restaurant boasts a menu where fresh ocean delights are "cooked to perfection." Diners frequently rave about the scallop risotto and yellowtail entrée, highlighting the skillful preparation and authentic taste that make every bite memorable. With an inviting ambiance that complements the culinary artistry, Butterfly Café ensures every visit is a "beautiful experience," making it the perfect destination for seafood lovers seeking both quality and authenticity.

4. Mahina

4.2

Awesome(110)

Price: Expensive

• American • Marathon

Booked 9 times today

At Mahina, located in the heart of Marathon, Florida, diners are treated to a delightful fusion of classic favorites and authentic Caribbean cuisine, skillfully crafted by Executive Chef Pavy Keomaniboth. This Polynesian-inspired gem offers an unforgettable dining experience, complete with "phenomenal" service and "beautiful water views." Guests rave about the "top-notch" food and drinks, with generous portions that leave a lasting impression. The ambiance is unmatched, with options to dine al fresco on an oceanside patio, making it perfect for sunset lovers. Patrons consistently describe Mahina as an "amazing experience," highlighting its exquisite flavors and exceptional hospitality.

A photo of Salt + Ash at Hawk's Cay restaurant

5. Salt + Ash at Hawk's Cay

new

4.4

Awesome(32)

Price: Expensive

• American • Duck Key

Booked 40 times today

Salt+Ash is a bold new dining experience by Chef Jeremy Ford, rooted in the vibrant connecton between land, sea and fire. This truly farm-to-table concept celebrates the raw beauty of natural ingredients, expertly charred and delicately seasoned with the essence of the ocean. With a curated yet effortless coastal aesthetic, Salt + Ash offers a space where bohemian charm meets refined craftsmanship, inviting guests to savor every flavor and texture that tells the story of its surroundings. Here, the elements are not just inspiration, they're the foundation.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

Best American Restaurants in Key Colony Beach

Price

Regions

Areas

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Accessibility

5 restaurants available nearby

1. Angler & Ale at Hawks Cay

2. Lighthouse Kitchen + Bar

3. Butterfly Café

4. Mahina

5. Salt + Ash at Hawk's Cay

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable